dog advice, please

OK totally off top, way too weird suggestion..but if youve tried everything else, what have you got to lose?

How about one of the more reputable animal pyschics? Ok I know its weird, but maybe, just maybe they can help. I have heard good things about some of them.. if you go to one who has a good reputation and is not trying to rip you off.. msot do phone consultations.

I know its weird, but sometimes situations call for weird answers.. or at the very least maybe you could go to dog psychologist.

OK you may return from the twilight zone now.... :crazy:
 
PP_dog_fortuneteller.jpg


Sorry, just trying to visualize this...

Seriously, though, another valid option. :)
 
twinmomplus2new....

I just wanted to say that it must be very frustrating for you trying to decide what to do. As a mother your first and formost thoughts are for the protection of your children, as well it should be. But obviously you love your dog too and it is hard to even think of deciding the fate of a beloved animal family member. Many of us our also animal lovers and with this being the age of "disposable" pets it angers many people when someone mentions putting an animal to sleep. The bottom line is that none of us lives your life and we can only offer suggestions on what you can try, you will have to do what is best for you, your family and your dog.

I think some people on here have given some good suggestions. Have you tried joining any of the dog lists on yahoo? There may be some who can give you some more suggestions as well. I do think the vet should do a thorough exam on your dog if that hasn't been done already. Sometimes it's a health issue that causes odd behavior.

The best of luck!!!:hug:
 
You may wish to seek advice from an animal behaviorist (doggie shrink). These are legit specialized vets who can assist with analyzing pet behavior and helping train you how to correct/prevent problems. My rescue Scottie was actually refered to one before we got her. Don't know the outcome however, or if she was taken. Big difference with my dogs and yours is mine are each at 30 pounds or less.

Other suggestions sound good. It may be that your dog sees the 3 year olds as having a lower pack order and therefore she must protect them. You are in a very difficult situation and my heart and prayers go out to you, your family and the dog.

One possiblility to consider. I know you had her checked by the vet and found no obvious health problems. You also mentioned an ear infection. And the dog is getting to be a senior for her breed. Is it possible she could have a hearing or vision problem? These can be hard to diagnose. But if she is losing hearing or vision, it is possible your child scared her when her collar was grabbed. She may have bit out of fear, then realized what she was doing and quickly stopped before inflicting physical damage, because she knew it was wrong. My male Scottie stepped on a bee and was stung once. When I reached for his paw he mouthed me because he was in pain. But when he realized what he had done, he quickly stopped pressure and licked my hand while whimpering.

It sounds like you truly love your dog and have the highest concern for her future. If she is not to remain in your home, please contact additional rescue organizations, they may be able to find her a home away from children, even though another rescue group said she could not be rehomed.

My best, and please keep us posted.
-Jockaroo
 

Just a thought, although I know she is technically elderly for her breed, has she ever been spayed?
 
Yes, she wa spayed at 6 months. I did consult a behaviorist. And he said we could medicate her do some therapy but that the bottem line is I can not trust her with the kids. This is a known problem some ST's have and success treating it is limited.
 
This won't be a popular opinion, but as an owner/breeder and rescue volunteer of another giant breed (Great Danes) I have to say that it sounds like you have done everything correctly and shouldn't feel at all guilty if you have to make the difficult choice of putting her to sleep.

Since you've covered all your bases with training, medical issues, etc. I agree that this dog would not be placeable in another home. I know that our rescue would never take in a dog with known biting/aggression issues. It's too much of a liability and wouldn't be fair to the new family, or to the dog, who would most likely end up being more confused and escalating her behaviors.

With a giant breed dog, you need to be especially cautious and can't afford to take any risks, especially with children involved. It's obvious to me that this is a heartbreaking decision for you and you in no way consider your dog to be "disposable." 6 is definitely considered elderly for a St. Bernard, and you're right that it's most likely a form of senile dementia if that is common in your breed. I think the kindest thing you can do for her is to humanely put her to sleep and treasure the memories that you've had together. It sounds like you've made her a wonderful home for the past 6 years. You have nothing to feel guilty about.

Good luck with your decision...

Jynohn
 
/
We had the very unfortunate experience of having to put down a beautiful, healthy dog because of severe behavioral issues. It was one of the worst things we've ever had to do. He was a perfectly fine dog until our children were born and started walking. Then, he became so aggressive that we feared for ourselves, much less our children. He attacked me and DH on several occasions breaking the skin and we couldn't trust him at all around the children. After speaking to the vet and begging the rescue league (springer spaniel) to take him, they both recommended putting him down as he wouldn't be able to be placed somewhere else. It was horrible.

But it also was the correct thing to do. I love dogs (have the best dog in the world right now - yellow lab) so much but if it's a choice between a dog or my children's safety, it's a no-brainer. I'm sorry you have to go through this and wish you luck.
 
Seems like most of the posters think biting a child is "natural, animal behavior." My vet does not hold with this attitude. We had a really cute, funny rat terrier that we were all in love with. We got him when he was about 10 weeks old, from a friend who couldn't care for him. After a while, it became apparent that he was gonna be a "one-boy" dog, and liked my oldest son the best. At first, he didn't act aggressively towards the other children, just preferred to sleep/play with my oldest.

When he was about 6 mos. old, he bit my son for the first time. Very small bite, did not break the skin, no big deal we thought. If he really meant to harm him, he would have broken the skin, right? This was our thinking at the time, we did our best to watch over him and remove him from the situation if he seemed to be getting hyper. Then, we left him with my MIL when we went on vacation. We returned to find her with a huge bruise on her thigh, when I asked about it, she laughed and said Oreo bit her when she picked up the neighbor's baby. Again, everybody said "oh, that's just the way animals act sometimes, if he really wanted to hurt you he could have."

I called the vet, to ask what kind of behavioral modification training we could do. To my horror, he advised that we put him down. The whole household starting crying, but the vet insisted this was not a situation we could ignore, and that if a dog starts biting, they must not be given to another family. I begged the vet for another solution, and he grudgingly agreed that if we were very, very careful we could try to watch for the danger signs.

For a year, we watched over this dog, removing him if he seemed to be about to bite. Finally, when he was about 3 yrs. old, my oldest came in and asked "where are the Band-Aids?" I told him where they were, then it sank in "why do they need a Band-Aid?" Although they tried to hide it from me, Oreo had bitten my younger son so hard that he almost tore off his left nipple. Out of nowhere, he launched at my son and bit him. I contacted the vet, and he stated that there was nothing else but to put him down. He stated that it was an especially dangerous sign that the bites got worse over time, and that the dog used a tearing motion when he bit my son. My vet stated that there is no behavioral modification for biting, and that we would have to keep him in quarantine for 10 days to watch for rabies, even though we were current with our shots.

This was the hardest thing I've ever had to do. Do I feel guilty, of course I do. But while my dog was being held in quarantine, I would go visit him so he wouldn't be lonely. During one of my visits, an assistant at the vet's office saw my dejected attitude, and said "I'm so glad you're doing the right thing. I didn't, couldn't put my dog down, and she bit my daughter in the face and left scars."

You have to do what is best for your children. We have two Cavalier King Charles Spaniels now, and they are beloved members of our family. After the horrible incident I've described, I searched the internet to find the right breed for our situation, so that this would never happen again.

Good luck, I know it is very hard.
 
Just a :hug: for you...you obviously love your dog but your children have to come first. Do what you feel is right but please do not feel guilty about it.
 
You love your dog and have done your best for her.
You love your children and now must do the best for them.

So hard....we understand....now I'm crying....:hug:
 
Well Sophie is still here. I have padlocked the back gates at all times, so the little ones can not inadvertantly let her out. I am going away for the weekend and she will have her yearly exam and work up on Friday afternoon. They are aware of the situation and are going to be watching her closely and give me an assessment on Tuesday.
I am not ready to do what they have suggested.
Simply not ready.
I know intelectually I should, But emotionally I just can't.
As others have said she is elderly now, her life span could be 8 years. I do have someone that offered to take her and have her be a country pet. This I am not willing to do. She is ahouse dog. She goes outside to pee and comes right back in. I will not let he rgo to someone who thinks dogs should be outside all day. She would get pretty confused not being in her nice air conditioned house. Wrong for me for sure.

I am also going away for 10 days in August. If there are any incidents regarding safety with her and the kids. Then I will not pick her up from boarding I will have them put her down at that point. After she has been out of the house for awhile it will be a bit easier if it ends up having to be done.

Believe me I am not taking this lightly.... What you don't all know is that when my dd was 5. She was bitten by a neighbors yellow lab... And had to have plastic surgery and recieved more than 50 stitches in her face. She is now 17 and still has the scars. She is very lucky she did not lose her eye. So I am not taking this lightly that was the worst day of my life. And I surely do not want to repeat it. thanks for all your input.... I will let you know if anything changes.
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE







New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top