DL vs. WDW - What's the big difference?

lisakramer

Mouseketeer
Joined
Apr 27, 2011
Messages
332
I wanted to post something for others that haven't been to DL, but are WDW veterans...

I've been going to WDW almost every year since I was about 5 years old, that's 30+ trips by now. We are DVC at Saratoga and BLT. I've been as a honeymooner, babymooner, mom of a toddler, etc. I'm the family/friends Disney vacation planner. So, I know my WDW pretty well.

BUT - My little family of 3 just got back from a 5 night stay at Disneyland. The Disneyland podcast team was kind enough to have me on the show and help me make some plans for our trip. Here are my thoughts on the most important differences between DL and WDW.

In general, things are more relaxed/less structured at Disneyland.

Dining - Yes, you can make dining reservations, but it's not as big of a deal as it is at WDW. I made reservations for all of our sit down meals, because that's what WDW has trained me to do. We were there in low season, and nothing was crowded. We could have walked right in to all of the places we ate without a reservation. This could have allowed us a lot more flexibility than we normally have at WDW.
Another point about dining at DL is that all of the places, from counter service to sit down - OFFER DIFFERENT FOOD CHOICES - seriously. It's not just burgers and chicken fingers at every place. It's worthwhile to look at menus online so that you have an idea of the different offerings. And, believe it or not, the FOOD IS ACTUALLY GOOD. No, really, it is. It's overpriced, but it's actually tasty.
Character dining seems different as well. We had breakfast at the Plaza Inn. It was a breakfast buffet and there were a lot of nice choices for food. But the character interaction is the real difference. The characters are on their own, no visible handler. There are pros and cons to that method. Pros - the characters wander around and spend a great deal of time with each family. They truly are in character and do lots of fun acting and clowning around. Cons - Rude people will take advantage and drag the characters over to their table with no concern over the other guests, and there are no handlers to stop them.

Photopass - It's an interesting mix of differences with DL photopass photogs vs. WDW photogs. Cons - Not as many photographers in random places around the parks. They are located at the main points you would expect, castle, etc. Pros - Every single character we saw had a photographer with them. The photographers seemed more interested in posing your family and working with you to get really good pictures. We had one photographer in particular on Main St that we visited twice. He acted like we were celebrities. He waited till people were out of the background of our pictures, he moved us around, he took a lot of magic shots with our son, he was great! This was similar for a lot of the photographers we encountered.

Downtown Disney - You have to walk through downtown to get to the parks if you are staying on property. At first I was irritated by this because I'm not used to it, but walking through downtown on our way back to the hotel became one of my favorite things by the end of the trip. Downtown at DL is very different from WDW. It has an energy that WDW downtown does not have. Everything is very close together, dining, shopping, entertainment, all next door to one another. The shops are unique and interesting. The carts/booths are a nice variety and the people working them do act obnoxiously and try to grab you out of the crowd.
My husband and son had some "man time" and built a car at Ride Makerz. We shopped the Disney store. I loved Wunderground gallery and the Vault. The restaurants offer a nice variety of choices. It seems like there are people out and about all day. I saw a lot of people taking pastries and coffee back to the hotels in the morning.

The Parks -
DL - There is so much history in this park. I loved the feeling of walking in the park that Walt worked in. There is a sense of history and pride in the CM's and the guests alike here that is not the case in WDW. Speaking of CM's, we did not have a single negative experience while on vacation. Everyone went out of their way to make sure we having a wonderful trip. Everyone took notice of my son's bday button and made a point to talk to him. We took a tour, and our guides were fantastic. They were very fun and all of the kids on the tour had a blast.
In terms of attractions, there were some things that were down for rehab, but everything else was open and appeared to be in good condition. We waited less than 10 minutes for every attraction. Something to be aware of at DL is that everything is very close together and that looking at the map can be misleading. If you're accustomed to WDW, you'll think that something is halfway across the park and you don't want to walk "all the way over there", chances are good that it's really a lot closer than it looks on the map. Because things are so close together, it's easy to miss pathways that lead to some attractions. Try to go slowly and really watch where you are going. The details in this park are amazing.
Do take the train, even if it's not really your thing. There is a really cool dinosaur scene on the way to the Main St station that is worth seeing. Also, take the monorail, even if it's just roundtrip. It's very different from the monorail at WDW. And it's possible to ride in the front with the pilot, which is super cool!

DCA - I can see why this park was not well received at first, there are some things that are fairly generic that have been "Disneyfied". But there are a lot of fun things to see and do here. The most obvious is Carsland. The theming is beyond anything I have seen before. You truly feel like you are in the movie. The rides are fun, the shops are cute, and the food is good. My son fell in love with Mater's Junkyard Jamboree. Thankfully the lines for Mater and Luigi are short. We waited about 20 minutes at park open to get on Radiator Springs Racers. I would have liked to ride again, but my son didn't want to do it again. Oh well. Again, there were attractions that were down for rehab, but it wasn't a deal breaker.
This park feels larger than DL does. I think it's because things are more spread out here. Walking from one side of the park to the other side is more like what you'd expect at WDW.
We saw the Mad Hatter party one night, but didn't have the chance to hang out and enjoy the music. I'd like to go back and be able to enjoy this next time. It looked like it was a lot of fun.
Bug's Land - My son really enjoyed all of the rides, theming, etc. As a parent I did not enjoy this part of the park. It was a major time suck. All of the rides take very few kids at a time, so there is a lot of time spent in line here.
Do check out the building with Animation Studio, Turtle talk with Crush, etc. There is a lot going on in that little area and it's all a lot of fun. The Crush show is different from the one in Epcot, which is nice.

Summary -
I was pleasantly surprised by our experience at DL. It really is a different experience from WDW. So many people seem to think that it's just a smaller, older version of WDW and that is not the case at all. If you have any interest in Disney history, it is well worth the trip for that reason alone. For my family, I'll be planning trips west as often as possible now.
I would say that our trip was really special because of the CM's and the character experiences. People seemed genuinely happy to interact with us. The characters were over the top! Not just sign the book, pose for the picture, these guys were having fun with every kid. It really made a huge difference in my opinion of the parks. The food choices and quality were another big factor in my decision to come back more often.
Sure there are attractions that are different from WDW, but in my honest opinion it's the people that make me want to come back.
 
Sounds like a fantastic trip!
We are hoping to do a our first trip to Disneyland this year for our 30th anniversary!
 

My family are WDW veterans who spent three days in DL this summer. Our reaction was.... mixed.

Driving around the LA/Anaheim area is like being in the 9th circle of hell.

DCA is a great park, especially CarsLand. California Screamin' and Radiator Springs are my favorite Disney Park rides ever. But we were kind of disappointed in DL.

If we ever go back, we will fly and stay at one of the hotels we can walk from, and go on some Wednesday in October when the locals are all at work.
 
Disneyland is what WDW's parks used to be like... I'm a huge fan of DL and DCA and desire to return there more than WDW...

Food choices are good and have not been hurt in quality by any meal plans, no massive pre planning effort (which is mainly because DL caters to locals who would riot if it was like WDW), attractions that receive well timed maintenance (because, again, locals notice these things and complain loudly)...

DLR is fantastic... I like going and I could ride Pirates 20 times.... Easily, the best themed attraction ever made and the best version of the attraction worldwide...
 
We are WDW passholder's and this past October, we did our Honeymoon at DLR. We upgraded our pass and spent 8 great and awsome days at Disneyland.

The parks are great and I want to go again.

But with that said. The truth is, all of the parks at WDW and DLR are similar. What makes one better then the other, is your emotions behind it.

DLR is the first, Walt walked it. The entertainment has a better pool to pull from. The parks don't have a rush and plan everything out mentality.

WDW - My wife and I had are first date at EPCOT. I proposed to her on the People mover. With just those two things alone, there is nothing in the world that any park ever can top that. And that isn't counting all of the other memories made.

That is the real difference between Disney Land Resort and Walt Disney World.
 
We are WDW passholder's and this past October, we did our Honeymoon at DLR. We upgraded our pass and spent 8 great and awsome days at Disneyland.

The parks are great and I want to go again.

But with that said. The truth is, all of the parks at WDW and DLR are similar. What makes one better then the other, is your emotions behind it.

DLR is the first, Walt walked it. The entertainment has a better pool to pull from. The parks don't have a rush and plan everything out mentality.

WDW - My wife and I had are first date at EPCOT. I proposed to her on the People mover. With just those two things alone, there is nothing in the world that any park ever can top that. And that isn't counting all of the other memories made.

That is the real difference between Disney Land Resort and Walt Disney World.

This is probably true. I went to WDW twice as a kid with my parents but the first park I ever took my kids to was DLR. My heart and soul is in DLR now. I have taken the kids to WDW but nothing beats that first visit to DLR. I remember it every time I step onto Main Street there. I can't wait to get back. Add to it that I don't love the transportation issues at WDW and DLR became my go to "happy place". My kids prefer it too. Plus their cousins live there and its the only time they get to see them. It is just the best place in the world to us. Don't get me wrong, I like WDW too. (And I would rather be there than home in the snow!) Living on the east makes it harder for us to get out west so WDW wins in proximity. I also prefer the food options at WDW and love Epcot. But DLR is where I wish I could be every single time.

I agree with you, it is probably the emotion behind it. The feeling of joy I got from seeing DL through the eyes of my then three year old and having them "grow" up on it there and not at WDW, that makes it feel like "home" to me. Even when I go on soaring in WDW and see DL at the end, I cry. :lmao: I am a big sap though.
 
Love your summary, and am going to copy on the DLR board because we get a lot of people who like to read the WDW expert's opinion of DLR.


I agree with you, it is probably the emotion behind it. The feeling of joy I got from seeing DL through the eyes of my then three year old and having them "grow" up on it there and not at WDW, that makes it feel like "home" to me. Even when I go on soaring in WDW and see DL at the end, I cry. :lmao: I am a big sap though.

Yeah, I'm a sap right there with you. ;)
 
What a great report! We're also WDW veterans and planning to do a DL trip within the next few years. (It was supposed to be this year, but we got a monster deal on a PAP for WDW.) What is considered to be the low season at DL?
 
Grew up in Cali where a trip to DL was not a big deal. It was the kind of place you could wake up on Sat morning and say "I feel like it's a Disney kind of day" or you could wait for the kids to get home from school and be "Change cause were going to Disney tonight" and it wasn't a huge hassle. I've only been to WDW once and it didn't feel like that to me. Even if you live close it just doesn't seem conductive to that kind of spontaneity but that could just be my impression.

Best advice I can give you as an old head.
1. Shoot for weekdays during school times. Yeah your kids might have to make things up but it is so empty.
2. If you have to go in the summer take a local's approach. When are the tourists going to hit the park? Early right? They got kids bouncing off the walls in excitement. Take the kids to the pool or something and go later (5pm or so). By then these families have worn themselves out and are headed back for food and sleep. Stay till close.
3. If you are doing a full day in summer at the park and here I'm speaking more toward old DL and not Adventure. Again try to leave the coasters for rope drop or later evening when the crowds get lower.
4. No Cali person in their right mind (unless it is a special occasion) eats in that park. The food might be great but it is three times as much as the restaurants literally across the street. try to eat out of the park, as far from Disney, as you can.
5. Fly into Ontario airport instead of LAX if you can. Traffic is a B in LA.
 
I am actually still in Anaheim and just finished up my first trip. I thought the night time entertainment was great. I saw World of Color, the fireworks and had the Fantasmic dessert package. They were all great.

I did notice something I found interesting and different from Disney World. It's a really small thing but it stood out to me. Has anyone else noticed that a lot of the girls/women wear Minnie ears at Disneyland? I swear I saw thousands of pairs of ears. I was there Thursday-Sunday so a lot of teenagers were around. It was cute but not something I have noticed in Florida.
 
Mickey or Minnie ears... one of those super nostalgic items that you can buy for not a lot. Many still have their first pair. I completely forgot to get a new pair, lost mine moving, and I kick myself. Not sure how it is at WDW but ears and the huge suckers are almost a must for my friends and I.
 
It's been like 5 years since I've been to Disneyland. But the more and more regimented WDW gets, the more and more I miss Disneyland. (I grew up in Southern California). I'm planning a trip there in October, and am seriously thinking about switching my Disney fixes out to DLR rather than WDW. We'll see if that actually happens, but it's tempting.

Sayhello
 
I will throw my hat into the ring since I too love both Disneyland and Walt Disney World, but for different reasons. For the theme park experience I think Disneyland wins. Both parks are crammed full of headliner attractions, and I think both parks require two full days to appreciate.
The parks at WDW all feel like half day parks to me, when compared to Disneyland. This is because Disneyland has crammed almost the same number of attractions into two parks instead of 4. With a few exceptions, the Disneyland version of the attraction is better than the same attraction at WDW.

When it comes to the Resort hotel experience, Walt Disney World wins hands down. While I think the Disneyland hotel is compatible to the Contemporary, and The Grand Californian is comparable to the Grand Floridian, nothing approaches the breadth of resort choices and activities at the World, throw in the water parks, and The Disneyland Resort just can't compete.

Anyone who has been to Walt Disney World should try Disneyland (stay on site if you can), and I would say the same to a Disneyland regular about Walt Disney World.
 
I agree with the hotel part. Since DL only has two and DLH has been there since I was young, they definitely don't have as many choices. However since extra magic hours are really the only bonus to stay at a DL hotel (no dining plan, etc.) if you are on a budget there are a ton of other hotels, which are really nice, really close. Like across the street close. The park doesn't have all that extra land around so think across the road like your neighbors house (some have a good neighbor deal with Disney which gets some perks but I don't know what). Hotels are the hardest for me to speak to cause when you live an hours drive away you don't bother and I haven't been back to DL since I moved to Nebraska.

The rides... I can say it is my personal opinion that Pirates at DL is the best. In fact, to me, I will never ride the one at WDW again it was such a disappointment. That is said though with the fact that Pirates is my favorite of all rides (except Mr. Toad and WDW didn't have it when I went)
 
I've missed most of this discussion but wanted to say that we love the parks on both coasts. We are basically WDW people (in fact we now live 2 miles north of the castle) but have been to DL/DCA several times, counting an ABD Back Stage Magic trip. We've really come to appreciate the unique things in DL that are missing from the MK. And DCA, now that CarsLand is open, is a really great park too.

The whole atmosphere is just different out in California. Can't really describe it. Once you get over the fact that DL's castle is smaller, and that it feels like somebody came into your house and rearranged the furniture, you begin to appreciate the subtle difference in "feel".
 
There's something about DL, it's so intimate. Everything is so close and full of history.
I've only been once and it was in a ABD trip so I did get spoiled with very little wait times.
It made things make sense, like Pirates. We go back in July, spending far much more time ( and a ABD trip too)
Were Wdw vets too, but DL started it all.
 
Lisa thank you for posting such a detailed comparison/report.

It's been a much discussed topic in our house lately. I do confess that the recent changes at WDW led me to looking at potential alternatives initially, although that is not the reason we would go if we did; I am now genuinely keen to visit Disneyland because the more I read about it, the more I want to go see it all for myself. You have actually answered a lot of questions I had. Thank you.
 















Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter DIS Bluesky

Back
Top