DisneyWorld Wins! How the Mouse Came to Defeat a Vegetarian and a Carnivore

itchin2go

When life gives you lemons, make lemonade!
Joined
May 8, 2007
Messages
3,375
Just back from a 5 day trip on Deluxe Dining, and let me just start by capitulating. As we told the kind server at Yachstman Steakhouse on our final day, "You win. We give up." Truly more food than we've ever ingested in a 5 day period, much of it too delicious for words, which would explain why we ate so much of it.

In summary: Everything was good. Some things were great.

These were our worthy competitors:

Hollywood Brown Derby
Flying Fish
Le Cellier
Kona
Big River Grille
Spoodles
Cape May Cafe
Akershus Storybook Princess Lunch
Beaches & Cream
Crystal Palace
Grand Floridan Cafe
Yachtsman Steakhouse

Let the battles begin....
 
My husband and I REALLY thought the DxDDP was going to be perfect for us. We used the regular DDP last year and ended up spending extra money on OOP meals because we leaned so heavily on "signature dining". I thought they had tailor-made this plan for us.

For the record, DH is heavily carnivorous, and I'm the plant-eater. My daughter (6) is the pickiest eater alive, which is just PONDEROUS since I think DH and I are fairly adventurous eaters.

Ok - on with the show: See, things started to go wrong from the very start, because I had made the utterly brilliant decision to start off our journey at the Brown Derby for lunch. That's a mighty big lunch!

After waiting in line most of the morning for one thing or another, we exited the HSM parade to the relative calm of the the HBD. Nice place. We had a couple of beers, which were a welcome treat after what felt like an unproductive morning. (By the way, we enjoyed the Studios, but it was our first time, so I wasn't prepared for all the waiting and the pace of things. I felt like I wasn't getting much accomplished. I think you just need a different mind-set than for the other parks. I'll be better prepared next time. :) ) I ordered the Goat Cheese Mushroom Tortelloni or -ini (not sure which), to be followed by the Noodle Bowl. DH ordered the mussels followed by the Tuna.

The mushroom goat cheese pasta thing was quite good. I'm not a mushroom lover, but these were uber-minced, so you got earthy mushroom flavor, but not chewy mushroom texture. Those tiny tiny mushroom bits were mixed with goat cheese and stuffed inside some pasta that was covered in a brothy tomato-y sauce. Pretty good. The tiny tiny mushroom bits are a good idea, and one that would make an appearance later in our journey as well....

The Noodle Bowl was pretty darn remarkable. It consisted of lots of noodles in a brothy red curry sauce, with some sugar snap peas and edamame, and a single chunk of panko-breaded tofu. While I don't eat meat, I'm not really thrilled with tofu either. So you could have knocked me over with a shred of panko when I tasted a bite of it and fell in love. The noodles were fine. The sugar snap peas were nice. The edamame was tasty. The freakin tofu was phenomenal. Utterly delicious. The crust was slightly sweet (from coconut, I believe - I looked up the recipe :) ), and crunchy and just delicious. I could have eaten three chunks of the stuff. There was also a spiky piece of lemongrass rising up out of the bowl. It was striking (no pun intended :) ), but fairly useless. It made my bowl look fancy though. I liked that....

This is the part when I have to admit that my descriptions of my husband's meals (and my daughter's, for that matter) will be far sparser than those of my own choices. I didn't choose them or taste them (for the most part), so I can only go on what I was told ... and the truth is, I wasn't paying a lot of attention in this case since I was engrossed in the tofu-nirvana in front of me.

Here is what I know though: DH LOVED the mussels. When he made this remark to the server, she said that he absolutely HAD to try the mussels at LeCellier because they were even better. Mental note made, he went on to his entree, which, as I recall, he liked. Sorry for the lack of details here. It was the first day and is kind of a blur by now. The little one was starting to get antsy at this point -- you know how it is.

My daughter had chicken noodle soup which she wouldn't eat, and a hot dog and french fries, which she hardly ate any of. :confused3 She was a little tired of sitting still that long, so we elected to forego dessert and head back into the "Studios".

In summary - HBD is a nice place with excellent food, but for me, it was too heavy for lunch. Bad planning on my part. So we start the adventure stuffed at 1:00 on day one!

Fun fact to take away: If you have never tried tofu, THIS is the place to start!

Next up: Flying Fish ... yum!
 
Small side note before I move on to the Flying Fish (and I may not get there until tomorrow!). We went with several restaurant choices that were not in the original plans, namely Big River Grille, Spoodles, and Beaches and Cream. While Beaches gets good reviews, the other two tend to be on shaky ground. I liked BRG and Spoodles WAY more than I thought I would. I think my expectations for BRG were terribly low, so that may have been a factor, but I genuinely liked the meal I had there. I really believe that the appetizers and desserts we had at Spoodles were the best of the trip. Definitely the desserts - YUM.

Also, Akershus gets mixed reviews. I liked it more than I expected to for what that's worth.

The sleeper hit of the trip was the Grand Floridian Cafe. My husband says the sandwich he had there was the best sandwich he's ever had in his life. "Go back and tell your message boards that," he said... :rotfl:

Detailed reviews of all of these will follow. I just wanted to throw those thoughts out there while I was thinking them. They could be lost at a moment's notice, you know....
 

Great start!

I dont blame you, write it down now or forget it, I am the same way :lmao:
 
So, we tried the Flying Fish for dinner. Walked over from BCV -- first time seeing the Boardwalk. What a charming place! The restaurant is just beautiful inside - great attention to detail. Elegant, fun and casual all at the same time, if that's possible.

I started with a delicious wine, while DH had a PERFECT dirty martini. We munched on bread and butter (don't you just love that giant slab of butter they give you at restaurants in DW? YUM!), while we decided on appetizers: the artisanal cheese selection for me, and the lobster soup and sandwich for DH. The little one chilled at the Sandcastle Club for the night (she loved it), so we could have a relaxing dinner.

Let me first say that we love cheese samplers. We tried the cheese plates last year at Cali Grill, Jiko and Artist Point, and also sampled the one at Yachtsman this year as well, so we've done a bit of cheese plate comparing and contrasting. Cali Grill and FF are pretty much neck and neck on their cheese plate expertise. The others fell a bit short.

Anyway, great cheese plate at Flying Fish. It came with some delicious raisin toast. I pretty much ate everything I was given. The highlight was a very flavorful cheddar that bordered on being parmesan-y. YUM!

DH's dish is described as "Maine Lobster Soup and Sandwich - lobster bisque, celery root, leeks, fresh and sundried tomatoes, petite lobster BLT." So basically a lobster bisque with a tiny lobster sandwich. DH would have bathed in the lobster bisque. The sandwich was cute, but not as mind-blowingly delicious, according to DH.

Flying Fish doesn't offer a vegetarian option on the menu, so I inquired. My two choices were to have the shrimp pasta dish sans shrimp, or to have a composed plate of various side dishes. Maybe I should have gone with the pasta, but some of the side dishes sounded SOOO good. The highlight of the plate ended up being the "calabaza squash-laced risotto di carnarolli". It was yummy. The other sides, while having been culled from different entree choices, all ended up to be pretty much just roasted vegetables. Now, I like roasted veggies, but this resulted in 3 portions of mixed roasted veggies, with one portion of risotto. The risotto was really tasty, but I should have gone with the pasta.

DH had this: Pan-roasted Local Florida Day-boat Stone Bass - parsnip-apple puree, rapini, duck confit, chanterelle mushrooms, porcini duck jus. Ok – who knew that parsnip-apple puree was THAT good? Seriously, that was the most memorable thing I ate on the whole trip. I don't really know what a parsnip tastes like, but the dish tasted kind of like mashed potatoes with sage, only lighter, less starchy and slightly sweet ... and WAY more delicious than mashed potatoes. I am searching out parsnip recipes based on that dish. It tasted kind of Thanksgiving-y to me. Too good to describe. DH loved the whole dish. He wanted to go back to the Flying Fish before the trip was over.

For dessert we had these: Me -- Warm Valrhona Chocolate Galette and DH -- Warm Molasses-laced Pecan Tart with praline ice cream, maple anglaise, spiced port wine and chai tea cream. These were both stand-out desserts. The tart came with a little shooter of spiced port wine. Neat presentation.

Bottom line, despite my roasted veggie overload, we will definitely be returning to the Flying Fish. Definitely a signature dining experience.

Fun fact learned here: Parsnips are a highly underrated vegetable. That parsnip-apple puree was to-die-for.
 
Wilma-bride -- I sadly, did not have the guts to take pictures of my food. I am indebted to all of the dis-ers who do, but I just couldn't bring myself to do it. I will try to work up the courage to do it next time (which I hope will be October!) For now, I will just have to try to describe the food well enough to make up for the lack of pictures. Hope I'm up to it!
 
You are doing an excellent job on the descriptions, sometimes that is better than pictures because you are describing the taste.
You are making me really hungry. I'm on WW and get weighed tomorrow, so I'm trying to make up for being bad the rest of the week.:sad2:

Deb
 
You are doing an excellent job on the descriptions, sometimes that is better than pictures because you are describing the taste.
You are making me really hungry. I'm on WW and get weighed tomorrow, so I'm trying to make up for being bad the rest of the week.:sad2:

Deb

Thank you! You are too kind! Good luck on your weigh in tomorrow.
 
On our second day, we planned to go Epcot. We ate at Le Cellier that evening, but had counter service and snacks during the day. Here are my thoughts on the counter service and snacks:

We had a couple of egg and cheese croissants from the Beach Club Marketplace before heading out. These were surprisingly good. I guess I don't expect much from pre-cooked eggs that have been sitting in a warming device for some period of time, but these were good! Basically, it was a big slab of eggs and cheese that they slapped onto a croissant. The eggs were actually warm, tender and well-seasoned, and of course, the croissant was good, so ... this is really a good breakfast option.

At Epcot, we conquered Future World in the a.m. and then headed to World Showcase. We were hungry by that time, and stopped at the first outpost: Mexico. Now, I've heard virtually no good reviews of the Cantina, but I like Mexican food. I mean, can someone really screw up nachos? In a word, YES. They weren't inedible or disgusting, but they were a little south of "ok" -- certainly not worth the calories or the $$$. The nachos consisted of chips, seasoned meat, refried black beans, cheese sauce, pickled jalapenos and chopped tomatoes. No salsa. Kinda blah. The seasoned meat was greasy with a capital G. I know this because of the grease slick underneath the chips. The black beans were just ok. The cheese sauce, well, it was cheese sauce, nothing more, nothing less. They had little packets of "salsa", but the stuff was less flavorful than even Taco Bell sauce (which I like, actually). We got a side of guacamole, too, and it was the best food we tried there.

I wanted to like the place, but I didn't. What a lovely setting for such disappointing food. Oh, well. The margarita was delicious -- slushy and tart -- mmmmm! I won't go back to the Cantina except maybe for liquid refreshment, but I think I can get that from a kiosk...

On to Germany where we had a pretzel, a bratwurst and a beer. I feel like everyone has probably had these items there, so I hate to take up much time reviewing them. To sum up, Germany is "Old Faithful" for us. The food never disappoints. What DID disappoint was the rude lady we encountered in Germany. DH was in line for food, and my daughter and I turned to look for a table. Lo and behold, there is just ONE table left, and it's about 2 feet from us. So, I grab my daughter's hand and head toward the table. Just then, another lady frantically tells her two little boys (by name, just don't recall what they were) to hurry up and sit down in those chairs! "Just go! Hurry!" The two little boys go around, past and in front of me -- one on the left and one on the right and collapse into two chairs at this table. By the time they plopped down, my daughter and I were inches (like 3 maybe) from the table. There is no doubt in my mind that the lady saw that it was the last table, saw us heading for it and had her little angels (and they were cute kids, maybe 6 and 8?) do her dirty work for her. I just stood there and said, "You have got to be kidding me." The little kids just looked at me wide-eyed. I don't think they even knew what they had done. One of them then said, "Oh, were you sitting here?" Well, no, I wasn't sitting there, but I was about a milli-second from sitting there before YOU -- with your fast-little-boy-legs raced around me and plopped down. Grrrrr. I turned around and looked at the lady. She averted my stare, so she knew what was up. Nice. At some point, this lady felt bad about the whole thing (probably because she noticed the cast on my daughter's leg -- yes, lady -- you just beat out a handicapped 6 year old for a table - yay for you!), because just as we were making another lap around the table area to try to find a place to sit (with food in hand, mind you), she tried to get our attention to tell us to take her table. I guess she THOUGHT she would feel good about being sneaky and rude (and using her progeny to do it, I might add), but ultimately, it didn't feel that good, what with having to watch my little one wobble around on her big purple cast looking for a place to sit. We ignored her and went outside and leaned on the wall next to the fountain. As my husband said, it's meant to be street food! We finished up our food only to look up and see that her family STILL had not gotten their food. We would have eaten and finished by the time her family needed a seat. I KNOW I got TOO mad about it, but seriously, I felt like I was on an episode of the Amazing Race and there were only enough seats on the plane for one team... Disney World is not a competition, people!

Thank goodness for the beer!:drinking1
 
DH and I were on our own again this evening, and anxious to try Le Cellier. Such a polarizing place! Seems like it was the darling of Epcot for so long and now there’s all this backlash. Long story short, we liked it and will definitely return next time.

First off, the Cast Members in Canada are just engaging. By and large, I found them to be so easy-going and friendly and just fun. Patrick was our server and he fit that mold perfectly.

We ordered a bottle of wine (Canadian, of course), and then they brought the bread. Of course, I had heard about pretzel bread and all the hype. I had thought to myself, “How good can it be?” I mean, I like pretzels and I like bread, but what’s the big deal? Well, I still can’t really explain what the big deal is, but the stuff is really good. I don’t know why it’s such a novelty that the stuff feels like bread and tastes (and I mean – DEAD-ON) like a pretzel, but it is kind of intriguing. It shouldn’t be, but it is. Whatever. Really good stuff. Thumbs up for pretzel bread. The other two breads were ok. I love bread in any form, really, but they paled in comparison to the pretzel bread.

So, I ordered THE soup, and DH ordered the mussels. I knew the soup had bacon in it, and I chose to ignore that. I mean, it is THE soup. It was good. If I had never heard any hype about it, I probably would be more enthusiastic. It’s fairly thick, golden in color, with bits of bacon all through it. It probably tastes more of bacon than of cheese – smoky and comforting. It’s GOOD cheese soup. REALLY good with pretzel bread. It’s just not turnip-apple puree good. :lmao: Ha! I did really enjoy the soup. I would probably order it again.

DH adored the mussels. He agreed that they were better than the ones at HBD. I think that is probably because there was bacon in the dish. The menu description says, “served chowder style with applewood smoked bacon and potatoes”. You could probably cook my shoes chowder style with applewood smoked bacon and potatoes and they’d turn out tasty – you know?

For his entrée, he had the Le Cellier Mushroom Filet Mignon - with Baby Bella wild mushroom risotto, white truffle and herb butter sauce, topped with fried parsnips. Yes, the fried parsnips were delicious. He loved this meal. He loudly recommended it to anyone within earshot of us. The comment was something like, “This Kansas City boy has never had a finer steak.” It’s funny because he had a hard time deciding on his entrée. He initially gravitated toward the signature filet, but I warned him against it since I’ve read so many reviews from dismayed guests who were heartsick that their filet was smothered in barbecue sauce. So, moral of the story, if you’re avoiding Le Cellier because you’re fearful of that barbecue-y filet, rest easy, there are other dishes that might strike your fancy.

I had the Heirloom Squash Ravioli - topped with roasted chanterelle mushrooms and finished with brown butter and smoked paprika oil. That description is from the menu. I don’t recall it being mushroom-y at all. There was also some shaved cheese – a good sharp asiago-esque white cheese. The dish was big and beautiful and tasty. It was not a knock-out though, because I found it kind of hard to get all the flavors in one bite. So, depending on what I got onto my fork, the bite was either really tasty or just ok. Halfway through it, my husband asked me what I thought of it, and I was too confused to give an answer. I was still deciding, I think. Or maybe it was the wine… The ravioli were large and filled with a fairly mild winter squash puree. The brown butter was pretty darn subtle. A bite of squash-y pasta with a bite of the sharp cheese was really good, but I think maybe there wasn’t enough of the cheese. I LOVE the idea of winter squash ravioli, and I also LOVE that Le Cellier has such an interesting vegetarian item on their menu. I just didn’t LOVE the dish, but I thought it was pretty good.

Unfortunately, we had no room for dessert. :sad1:

For me, this place was an experience, not just a restaurant. It was the whole thing that I loved: the cast members, the setting (the light fixtures were cool!), the wine, the bread -- the whole thing. We’ll definitely return.

Oh, before I forget, yes, the tables are close together. That wasn't a big deal for us. At one point, the lady at the table next to us began to tear into her husband about whether he was sick, "What's wrong with you? You never eat anything anymore. It's not just me that says it - it's everyone! Tell me what's going on with you!" He pretty much ignored her. :confused3 Kind of random. They ended up being nice though. The other couple next to us were celebrating their anniversary. The hubby cracked us up telling us how emasculated he felt because of the frou-frou green drink his wife made him order (probably to maximize the dining plan :thumbsup2). They were funny. At another time, sitting so close to folks could have cramped my style. Not so that night, for whatever reason. Truthfully, though, the tables are QUITE close together.

I don’t know if I have a fun fact for this one, except to say that I’m told that the mussels here ROCK. I know everyone knows about THE soup, pretzel bread, the steaks, but I don’t know if the Canadian mussel dish has the reputation it probably deserves.

Day three: Kona, Big River Grille and Spoodles
 
I'm enjoying your reviews. :thumbsup2 Thanks for taking the time to write them. Too bad about that lady in Germany. But at least she seemed to realize it, or maybe she felt bad about getting caught. Some people who do that sort of thing just don't have a clue:sad2:

Terri

:dance3: :dance3:
 
Loving your reviews, looks like we share the same taste in places. We did make it to Flying Fish twice on our last trip, lucked out on our last night, they were able to seat us at the bar.;)

I also adore the mussels at LeCellier and the mushroom filet is amazing.

Curious as to whether you guys tried the mussels at Spoodles, I thought they were the BOMB!!!!
 
I love your reviews! Don't worry about the pictures; I can see everything in my mind from your wonderful descriptions (and from too much time perusing the food porn thread!). I hate that you didn't have room for Le Cellier's creme brulee, it was my favorite dessert of our trip.

Looking forward to more food adventures!
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE







New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top