After a whirlwind 8 days, 7 nights at the Boardwalk CL Standard, we've come to the conclusion that while the amenities are great, we just didn't take advantage of all there was to offer. I'm sure others will disagree, but just wanted to offer up our experience.
Our room was 4270, and outside the Club entrance. We had a very nice view of the gardens below, and could see Illuminations over the treetops. I liked the space of the room, and the couch/pullout bed, even though there were only two of us, it was nice to sit on the couch to read the paper or put your shoes and socks on rather than the taller beds. Beds were wonderfully comfy - and I wish I could have smuggled home those luxuriously soft pillows!!
We did hit the lounge for a quick breakfast before going to the parks, which consisted of oatmeal, meats and cheeses, lox and bagels, pastries, hard boiled eggs, some fruit. There was coffee, juices, yogurt cups and dry cereal also available. We were able to get back some days to take advantage of the appetizers and wine. Unfortunately, we found the selections pretty much the same every time we peeked in for the late afternoon dinnertime, (usually potato soup, meats and cheeses, a veggie dish of some kind, and breads, maybe a rice or pasta), with 2 white wines and 2 red wines. The desserts offered later also a little ordinary. Not a fan of the PB&J jellyroll, and that seemed to be a constant selection, and otherwise, most of the choices seemed "out of the box" types of cookies and sweets. Cordials were tasty, but limited in selection, (I think 4-5 different types).
Turndown service consisted of someone coming in to the room, and putting the pillows in a different arrangement, slightly adjusting the covers back, and leaving a couple of salt water taffies on the bed. If we were back in our rooms at that time, we preferred to not have the service, and just left the "Privacy" hanger on the door. General Housekeeping did well, but then we always straightened up our room before we left for the day. One day, there was no new coffee left, and the glasses and cups were not cleaned.
The CL check-in upstairs was great, and all the cast members we encountered were very friendly, and ready and willing to help in any way they could, but for us, and the way we "do Disney", I really am not sure the extra cost was worth it for us. I'm glad we did CL this trip, but I doubt we will do it again.
Next trip is in December in a Standard BWI room, so it will be interesting to make the comparison then.