Ok, Sherry, here is the list of movies I have watched and the ones I have recorded. I'm going to go to your list and try to find any I've missed.
Watched:
Christmas at Cartwright's
A Very Merry Mix Up
One Christmas Eve
Let it Snow
Royal Christmas
Christmas Under Wraps
Nine Lives of Christmas
The Christmas Ornament
A Cookie Cutter Christmas
Snow Bride
Hitched for Holidays
The Wishing Tree
Angels and Ornaments
On the DVR:
Silver Bells
Holiday Engagement
Naughty & Nice
Matchmaker Santa
Most Wonderful Time of the Year
Fir Crazy
Christmas Shepherd
Mr. Miracle
Best Christmas Party Ever
The Christmas Parade
Jamie --
Wow! I'm shocked you have had time to watch all of the movies you've watched! And you've still got a few really good ones coming up (saved on the DVR), such as
Most Wonderful Time of the Year,
Naughty or Nice and
The Christmas Shepherd!!
See if you can find these in the cable listings between now and 12/31:
- A Bride for Christmas (the two leads have a lot of chemistry, and the guy is cute)
- Trading Christmas (people swapping houses)
- Finding Christmas (people swapping houses again; one couple has a lot of chemistry)
- Farewell, Mr. Kringle (it's cute)
- Window Wonderland (a lot of snappy banter from the lead guy)
- Debbie Macomber's Mrs. Miracle (the original one, with Doris Roberts and James Van Der Beek -- it's very charming, unlike the recent Mr. Miracle
)
The movies are ending after 12/31, so I don't know how many more times those titles will be repeated in the next 2 weeks, but I think that there should be at least one more go-around for each one between now and December 31st, although they may run in the middle of the night!
You said you liked
Angels and Ornaments, you loved
Let it Snow and you disliked
One Christmas Eve. I think you also said that you were not impressed with
A Cookie Cutter Christmas. (I agree with all of those assessments, by the way!)
Were there any other standouts for you in the group that you have watched? Any others that you really enjoyed -- or really hated?
I will say that, on January 3rd, there is going to be a new non-Christmas Hallmark movie starring the girl from
Naughty or Nice and the guy from
Window Wonderland. It's called
Surprised By Love. I will be interested to see them together and see if they have any chemistry, as they were both good in their own individual Christmas movies. I think it could be a good one.
Also, sometime in January there is going to be a new movie called
Bridal Wave, starring the same two leads from
A Bride for Christmas (the ones that have a lot of chemistry). I think that one should be good too. It's not a sequel, but someone obviously likes those 2 actors together because they are being teamed up again.
So, now that the final two
new Countdown to Christmas movies of 2014 have aired on Hallmark, here are my final rankings (of only the new ones):
1.
The Nine Lives of Christmas -- It has not been bumped out of the #1 spot! It is adorable -- I just watched it again in full the other day, and I still smiled and laughed all the way through! It is a keeper, and it will stay on the DVR for a while! I now have to figure out where to place it in my list of overall favorite Hallmark Christmas movies;
2.
Angels and Ornaments -- It is closer to #3, #4 and #5 on the list than it is to #1, but because of the little twist in the movie it stays in the #2 spot for now;
3.
The Christmas Shepherd -- It's just a nice, believable story of two people brought together by a dog, but the first half of the movie is more dog-focused, while the second half of the movie is more romance-focused;
4.
A Royal Christmas (it can trade places with #3 and #5, depending on my mood) -- Sweet romance. Likeable leads. Jane Seymour is perfectly cast;
5.
Christmas at Cartwright's (it might also trade places with #3 or #4, depending on my mood) -- I like Alicia Witt and I liked the overall story. (This should have been
Mr. Miracle.);
6.
The Best Christmas Party Ever -- The lead actress is extremely pretty, and it's a sweet story. I liked the two leads together, for the most part;
7.
Christmas Under Wraps -- It was decent, but I didn't love it because I didn't think there was any need for the "twist" at the end (which was not really a surprise). Candace has a lot of charisma and charm, and it's hard to dislike anything she is in;
8.
A Cookie Cutter Christmas -- I think it could have been a funny story with different actors. I sensed zero chemistry between the lead actor and actress;
9.
The Christmas Parade -- This actress is very beautiful, but almost to the point of looking totally out of place in a Hallmark movie!

She looks more like a Playboy model than a pretty, approachable Hallmark actress! Her character is supposed to be a glamorous TV personality, so she fits the bill nicely, but I think that Brooke Burns would have been a better choice for the role (a little more accessibly glamorous and not so Playboy-ish). The woman gets together with a guy that she has
no chemistry with at all. Also, she becomes attached to the town and the kids awfully fast, and I felt like I missed scenes where she really bonded with them. Also, the ending with the Mayor was silly and unnecessary;
10.
One Starry Christmas -- Pretty actress. Goofy cowboy. No chemistry. Would have been better with different actors;
11.
Northpole -- Nice effects. Boring romance. Good for kids, but I was bored;
12.
Mr. Miracle -- This movie pales in comparison to the 2
Mrs. Miracle movies. Rob Morrow was not the right choice for the role. He was playing someone who was learning to be a human for the first time, but it misfired. I did not care about the romance part of the story either. The only redeeming quality is that the story was written by Debbie Macomber, whose previous Christmas tales include
Trading Christmas and
Mrs. Miracle; and
13.
One Christmas Eve -- Too much "puppy arrives and everything goes awry" mayhem. I didn't find it funny, I didn't find it charming. The girl singing was very annoying. The only good thing was the puppy.

An honorable mention goes to:
The Christmas Secret, starring Bethany Joy Lenz (it was a new movie on the Hallmark Movies & Mysteries Channel this year). It was a sweet story. It had a twist in it, but I was expecting a different twist! Without saying much more, in the first part of the movie I thought the twist was going to be one of a couple of different scenarios. It ended up being another scenario. It's not that it was so shocking, but it just wasn't the twist that I expected it to be.

