Sherry-
This will be my first visit to DLR since I was 6, and I am so excited to bring my own kids this year. We have spent the last two Decembers at WDW and absolutely loved Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party.

There is just something extra magical when it is an exclusive event in the evenings. I love Christmas in general. Honestly, I am not aware of how the Halloween parties are ran at DLR...so I am just going by the
MVMCP at WDW. Loved the snow on Main Street, special appearances by rare characters that are only out for parties, dance parties, people dressed in holiday attire with Santa hats, Christmas parade, and my kids loved the "free" cookies and hot cocoa. Ride lines were super short too.

I realize I could experience most of this without the party, but I would selfishly love to see Mickey's Soundsational Parade on non-party days and then the Christmas Parade at the party. We will also be there for 6 days....so having a 5 day hopper plus an additional party day would be great.
That being said, I am totally fine with the chance of them bringing back a 6 day ticket this year and keeping the Christmas festivities every night of the holiday season. Would be something different for us.
Either way- cannot wait for December to get here!!!
czmom -
I hadn't been following the saga of the 6-day ticket lately. Is there a chance of that happening, and that it might be brought back?
As for the Halloween parties at DLR -- since the event moved over to Disneyland and out of California Adventure, Disney began selling more tickets. I think that they sell too many tickets for each party night, and it leaves the parties not feeling all that...exclusive! To me, it feels like there are too many people at the party. It's not that the crowds are unmanageable or out of control, but it just feels too crowded for a party that people are paying a lot of money for.
I would rather that Disney added in a few extra party nights and kept the number of tickets sold to each event down. The only problem with adding in extra Halloween party nights during the Halloween Time is that the weekday hours are shorter to begin with (September and October at DLR are considered off-peak season, no matter how popular Halloween Time is), even without a party. The party requires Disneyland to close a couple of hours earlier (or more) than it ordinarily would close. To add in more party nights means to cut park hours short on more nights, and I don't think that would go over well with people who have interest in attending the Halloween party. SO that probably wouldn't work, but I do wish they would sell fewer tickets.
At WDW, certain things can be done that are not as easily pulled off at DLR. If someone doesn't wish to attend a Halloween party at WDW, they have 3 other parks to go to and a whole bunch of hotels to explore. At DLR, if someone doesn't want to do the party in DL he/she is forced over to DCA, or to roam aimlessly in DTD or the 3 hotels.
Good points about the Christmas party! I really appreciate that you took the time to explain it to me. First of all, how frustrating is it (for all of us) to know that Disney is probably fully aware of whether there will be a party or not this year (not to mention fully aware of any other holiday plans too), but that we won't find out for a while? So annoying! They know what they're doing. We know that they know what the plans are. They might as well just spill the beans now if there is going to be a party.
I can understand the appeal of being able to see 2 different parades during your trip! I hadn't thought of that. It is possible that there could be some characters at a party who are not out in the daytime. Disney limited the access to the Villains during Halloween Time last year but made them readily available at the Halloween party, so I would suppose that they'd try the same tactic with Christmas too.
I still think that this Limited Time Magic deal for 2013 is going to impact a party one way or the other -- either it will be used as an excuse to have a holiday party, OR it will postpone a party until next year. Somehow, that LTM thing is going to factor in to the fate of a party for this year.
In any case, yes, you'll have a great time whether or not there is an official party! DLR isn't as massive as WDW, of course, but we pack a lot of Christmas cheer into two parks, well over 700 Christmas trees and 3 hotels! Even the Goofy's Kitchen Christmas tree is adorable!
I understand the Christmas love that you have! It is my favorite time of year. I love every single thing about it. I don't think there is any part of the holiday season that I don't love. I have waxed poetic about Christmas time in my TRs, repeatedly. I don't even "celebrate" in the same way many people do, but I think I adore Christmas more than most of the people who do celebrate in the typical ways because I don't have the same stress involved. For me, I can just sit back and enjoy all of the wonders and beauty of it (while scarfing down my peppermint ice cream!) without the hassles that other people have!
I'm a little bummed about the CP but will find fun things to fill the gap. We're already planning on the BBQ at Big Thunder Ranch....soup at the Carnation Cafe....watching Alladin! So much to do and that doesn't even touch Cars Land and the new BVS.
TK -
As sad as I am that the CP will most likely not be doing a multi-night run this year, chances are that I will end up at DLR on that weekend of 12/7 or 12/8 anyway (most likely I would arrive on 12/8), so I still have a chance to try and see it if I feel like jockeying for a position. Unfortunately I don't think it will be as easy to nab seats as it was for me last year -- the crowds will be too big -- but it will be there if I want to brave it!
Don't forget some quality GCH lobby time, enjoying the carolers and Santa! You'll have a wonderful trip even without the CP, and it will be interesting for you to compare crowds between the week you're going and the time you usually go, over New Year's.
Plus, you have many new decorations to see, new trees to see, new gingerbread houses, Bell Ringers to enjoy, new Santas to meet, the Mad T Party Christmas thing, new Mardi Gras masks to see, etc.