Did I handle this problem correctly?

mandysbus

Mouseketeer
Joined
Jun 5, 2006
Messages
211
be forwarned, its long....

I'm embarassed that my kid would even think of doing something like this but....last monday DS(7) was playing outside (I'll admit that he was unsupervised in the sense that he was outside and we, DH and I, were inside. If he does not come in the house for a while, one of us will go out and see what he's up to) we've never had a problem with him wondering off or anything, he's either on our property or one or two houses up from our playing with those kids. DS will not cross the street or anything by himself.

well, last week he was playing with the little girl next door(she's 8 or 9 and in 2nd grade, DS is in 1st). well, we were getting ready to go somewhere so we went looking for DS. He's not out front, not next door and not at the next house. We are calling for him and get no response. Girl next doors mother comes out and she cant find her daughter either. DH walks up to the end of the block to another kids house (not a friend of DS but you never know). Not there. So after about 10 minutes of walking around the block, calling both their name (I was convinced that someone must have snatched them because my kid is not known to just wonder off), one of the neighbors found them in an old garage out back across the alley playing.

apparently they broke the side door to get into the garage (let me say the garage is in sad shape and the door was falling apart so i'm sure it didnt take much to get it loose). But I guess they threw a rock through the door glass to get in. There was a pink little girls type bike in the garage and some other toys and the neighbor girl admitted to wanting the pink bike so she talked DS into helping her. She claims DS broke the glass and He says that she did so it was hard to get a straight story out of either of them so I said they were both at fault. And now I found out from the girls mother that this is not the first time her daughter has done this type of thing (they just moved in a few months ago and she seemed like nice little girl).

So we had DS apologise to the people who owned the garage (who were very, very nice about the whole thing) and I let them know that we would gladly pay half to fix the door (I feel that the girls mother should cover the other half) and to let us know what they wanted to do.

As punishment for DS he is grounded to our property until the end of the school year, not allowed to go next door or to any friends houses. and I explained to him that was he did was very wrong and that It is the same as if someone would break into our house and take his things. and that if something like that comes up again, he needs to come and get a grownup.

fast forward until today, the neighbor kids are all out playing in the sprinkler in their yard and my neighbor comes over (she is the landlord and the mother w/kids rent from her) to ask if DS wants to come play in the sprinkler. I told her that he is grounded until the end of the school year. She asked if it is because of what happend last week. I said yes. She commented that my punishment is a lot harsher than the one her tenant doled out to her daughter. To me this occurance is a very big deal and not something I want a repeat of.

So I guess what I want to know is, did I handle this situation correctly? DS is our only child and I'm new to stuff like this.
 
When exactly is the end of the school year?

Maybe the little girl keeps repeating that kind of behavior because she does not recieve consequences.
 
the end of the year is in about a week and a half so his full punishment will have been about 2.5 weeks.
 
You did the right thing. If that girl keeps doing stuff then obviously her punishments aren't working. Sure your son will feel sad but he will never forget and will think twice before doing something like that again. As for the landlord- well I would have told her what I tell my kids - "I don't care what they are doing at ___'s house. This is our house and this is what we do here.":cutie:
 

I think you are handling the situation just fine. Too many parents consider kids' misbehavior "just being kids" and then things get worse. Technically, the kids were breaking and entering. That's a serious offense and it deserves to be taken seriously.
 
Why ask for approval of your parenting? do what you feel necessary and forget everyone else. You are instilling discipline in your child. I look at it this way, what would your parents have done. Think about that and do the same. The other little kid will end up in the gutter somewhere because her parents didn't love her enough to discipline her the right way.
 
be forwarned, its long....

I'm embarassed that my kid would even think of doing something like this but....last monday DS(7) was playing outside (I'll admit that he was unsupervised in the sense that he was outside and we, DH and I, were inside. If he does not come in the house for a while, one of us will go out and see what he's up to) we've never had a problem with him wondering off or anything, he's either on our property or one or two houses up from our playing with those kids. DS will not cross the street or anything by himself.

well, last week he was playing with the little girl next door(she's 8 or 9 and in 2nd grade, DS is in 1st). well, we were getting ready to go somewhere so we went looking for DS. He's not out front, not next door and not at the next house. We are calling for him and get no response. Girl next doors mother comes out and she cant find her daughter either. DH walks up to the end of the block to another kids house (not a friend of DS but you never know). Not there. So after about 10 minutes of walking around the block, calling both their name (I was convinced that someone must have snatched them because my kid is not known to just wonder off), one of the neighbors found them in an old garage out back across the alley playing.

apparently they broke the side door to get into the garage (let me say the garage is in sad shape and the door was falling apart so i'm sure it didnt take much to get it loose). But I guess they threw a rock through the door glass to get in. There was a pink little girls type bike in the garage and some other toys and the neighbor girl admitted to wanting the pink bike so she talked DS into helping her. She claims DS broke the glass and He says that she did so it was hard to get a straight story out of either of them so I said they were both at fault. And now I found out from the girls mother that this is not the first time her daughter has done this type of thing (they just moved in a few months ago and she seemed like nice little girl).

So we had DS apologise to the people who owned the garage (who were very, very nice about the whole thing) and I let them know that we would gladly pay half to fix the door (I feel that the girls mother should cover the other half) and to let us know what they wanted to do.

As punishment for DS he is grounded to our property until the end of the school year, not allowed to go next door or to any friends houses. and I explained to him that was he did was very wrong and that It is the same as if someone would break into our house and take his things. and that if something like that comes up again, he needs to come and get a grownup.

fast forward until today, the neighbor kids are all out playing in the sprinkler in their yard and my neighbor comes over (she is the landlord and the mother w/kids rent from her) to ask if DS wants to come play in the sprinkler. I told her that he is grounded until the end of the school year. She asked if it is because of what happend last week. I said yes. She commented that my punishment is a lot harsher than the one her tenant doled out to her daughter. To me this occurance is a very big deal and not something I want a repeat of.

So I guess what I want to know is, did I handle this situation correctly? DS is our only child and I'm new to stuff like this.

I say you did the RIGHT thing. AND I would NOT be encouraging a friendship between your child and that little girl either. She's 8 and already has "experience" in bad behavior, stay FAR FAR away, imagine when she's 10!
In the meantime, its just another reminder how fast something can happen, fortunately neither of them were cut or hurt or worse. Who knows what people have in garages, etc, some people keep their hunting rifles, power tools...Could have been so much worse.
I think if it was our house, the punishment would have been even worse, like he'd also be working off the money (chores) to pay for the damage.
 
I think you acted appropriately. Don't question yourself just because the other parent doesn't view it with the same seriousness-I guess that's why she has had this problem before.
 
Why ask for approval of your parenting? do what you feel necessary and forget everyone else. You are instilling discipline in your child. I look at it this way, what would your parents have done. Think about that and do the same. The other little kid will end up in the gutter somewhere because her parents didn't love her enough to discipline her the right way.


seriously? in the gutter? :confused3
 
Hi,

I think you handled it very well.

In addition to breaking and entering, this situation presents a real safety concern... he wandered off without asking permission. It's scary to think of what could have happened... he could have been injured or abducted.

You are disciplining him because you love him and care about his well-being. :love:

What makes a child happy, today, is not always what's best for them in the future.
 
Hi,

I think you handled it very well.

In addition to breaking and entering, this situation presents a real safety concern... he wandered off without asking permission. It's scary to think of what could have happened... he could have been injured or abducted.

You are disciplining him because you love him and care about his well-being. :love:

What makes a child happy, today, is not always what's best for them in the future.

I think you did right. We have to try and raise our children to be responsible and think of the consequences before they do things. The girl probably will continue to do what she does because she doesn't have to pay the consequences for the things she does.
 
trust your instincts... they guide you and tell you your own personal moral compass.

I don't know what my punishment would have been, but it is a good one... and remind him of it. Let him look out the window and watch the other kids... and have a conversation about why he can't go and play. If you back down now, he knows you will back down again. Use these next few weeks as 'teachable moments'. Beat it into his head, so in 5 years, he will say, "Remember when Mom...."

good luck :) (and I'd have supervised play with this little girl in the future)
 
You are only responsible for your child. If you have doubts as to the harshness of your punishment, then you might want to re-think it.

However, if you are only having doubts because someone else did not get in as much trouble, then you should stick to your guns.

In my opinion, there are times to show mercy to your child regarding behavior, but this incident is not one of them. Think about it in the same way you think about training him how to cross the street. You are potentially saving his life, because if he did this when he was older, he could go to jail for attempted burgarly or worse, someone could fatally shoot him for trying to break in.
 
The punishment certainly fits the crime. Stick to your guns, Mom! It's hard.
We all hate to do it, but you want him to remember it.

I'm not sure that anyone is going to be ending up in the gutter, either way, but I do know that taking action when something like this happens is necessary. You did the right thing!
 
Yeah Mom!!:dance3: I think you handled it perfectly! You made a big deal out of it and it is a big deal. Now your son has learned that others may make bad decisions and he shouldn't just go along with it. I really think you did the right thing. Its tough, this parenting stuff, but I really believe that consequences for misbehaviours do help a child learn.
Katy
 
Your punishment is perfect.

I am most certainly the meanest mom in my town, and I can live with that. My son's bike is grounded for a week (ending this Wednesday) because he took a bike ride after I specifically told him no. (And this was with an adult neighbor and his 2 kids; I knew exactly where my son was and that he was safe. )

I won't go through the litany of reasons why what your son did was wrong; you know them already and so does he.

I have taught too many teenagers over the years who have never learned that actions have consequences. That phrase is a mantra in my house, and my kids are sick of hearing it.

But I bet your son thinks twice before doing something so stupid again. The neighbor's child probably won't think twice.

Being a GOOD parent is tough. Being your kids' best buddy is a whole lot easier. And there will always be other parents who handle a situation differently. Not always better or worse, but differently. That's OK. You say you have a good son who isn't prone to bad choices. Your punishment may cause him to make a better one next time.
 
Sticl to your guns. You made a good call and the punishment is in no way excessive.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom