When you looked at your credit score and it was high, what company did you use? You can only get your actual credit score from MyFico. If you used anyone else, it was not your real score. Even now, I believe you can only get your credit score from two of the credit scoring agencies, although I forget which two. There are three...Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion. It stinks if you ask me--you used to be able to get all three, and credit is so important. Not fair that a credit bureau has this info and won't let the consumer have it.
I think it cost me $15-20 earlier this year to buy my credit score. Sometimes there are codes around that will bring the cost down. (Check creditboards dot com). Note that this will ONLY get you your scores. If you want a credit report and have already used your free ones from annualcreditreport dot com in the last 12 months, they will cost you extra. Do NOT use anything with "free" in its name. Hope this helped.