I think David is just brilliant, and the best interviewer on TV. Funny that those who judge him so harshly don't even watch him. He is great during campaign season, and I will never forget how his first live show after 9/11 lead the way for TV to go back to normalcy after the tragedy. That show alone made TV history.
But to each his own, I guess. Me? I will miss him terribly. His retiring is like the last nail in the coffin of my youth... (wow, that was awful and melodramatic, but hey, it's the way I feel.) Bye Dave...thanks for everything...it was a great ride...
ETA: I think the post 9/11 show, and the show where he presented the medical team after his life-saving surgery should answer any question about David being able to connect on an emotional level. The rest? it's done mostly for laughs. Some get it, some don't