Wow! Reading this thread is quite the eye-opener. We stayed CL at AKL back in January. We arrived just after midnight on DME so no luggage delivery (not available for late arrivals) or check-in in the lounge. We checked in at the front desk and had to wait a little while for anyone to even show up there to help us.
I initiated contact with the IPO. A few things I asked about they had no knowledge of (booking breakfast at Liberty Tree while Crystal Palace was closed for refurb and something with the golf). The tee times they booked for our guys weren't right. A few times when I was supposed to be contacted back, I wasn't.With the exception of booking the Sunrise Safari and Liberty Tree breakfast after several calls from me, they didn't really do anything for us. I took care of everything and had to fix the tee times myself. While there they weren't able to get us any reservations when we wanted to change our plans for dinner a few times as others have been able to do in the past but they did get my son an appointment at the Pirates League which was nice.
The lounge was a nice place to relax & regroup (considering the rooms were tiny compared to what we're used to at the Contemporary). The Sunrise Safari was mind-blowing! It was so awesome it made the extra cost for CL at AKL totally worth it. It was probably one of the most incredible Disney experiences we ever had.
Another thing that puzzled me: Why would they put DVC on the 6th floor where the lounge is then have their CL guests trekking it up the elevators every day? We were on the 4th floor. We weren't too terribly far from the elevators so it wasn't the worst thing in the world. I just wondered why they didn't put those DVC rooms on the 4th floor and kept the upper floor for club level?
Also, when we arrived only 3 of our 9 pieces of luggage made it on the plane with us. We were on the last flight so everything else had to come the next day. It was a rough start to the trip with the most frigid weather I've ever had to deal with (marathon weekend). The CL staff were extra sweet to us and really went all out to make sure everything made it to us as quickly as possible so I didn't have to stress myself out anymore than I already was trying to make sure the luggage was on the way. They even comped our rooms $50 each to help with the added cost of buying warm layers. Of course it wasn't enough to pay for all that we had to buy but the fact they even did that amazed me. It wasn't WDW's fault that the airline didn't put our luggage on our plane. That was awesome in itself.
I would do CL again if it was at a good price. I'd be skittish with the IPOs. I wish we could've had the incredible experiences some of y'all have had. We're booked at YC 9/14 - 9/24.
I didn't book club level just because I didn't feel it was worthwhile. HOwever, reading some of your wonderful experiences I'm almost tempted to try it again maybe for just half our stay if nothing else.