I have the Ashley satchel, I got it yesterday so I haven't used it yet. I really like it but I kind of look like an old fashioned doctor when I carry it in my hand, all I need is a long white coat and a stethoscope and I'll be all set for Halloween next year.

It does have a shoulder strap which I like in case I want to use it that way. Right now I have the Penelope in my cart and am debating on getting that instead and returning the Ashley.