We are considering club level for Sept 23 -30 at either the Boardwalk, Beach Club or Yacht Club. I understand there are renovations going on at each of these resorts. Which one do you recommend under the circumstances?
They are all nice. YC and BC are two halves of basically the same hotel. I mean there is a little difference between the decor and the CL food, but they are pretty similar and share a pool/shuttle boat/dining.
1. One way to decide is simply to choose the one with the lowest rates for your dates.
It has been a while since my most recent BWK stay, have not seen new renovations. Things to know: the pool is rather deep, and the hotel is rather sprawling. There is a nice quiet pool, but if your CL room in on the far end of the hotel, it a bit of a walk to the main pool. Many people don't mind though. It is a slightly shorter walk to HS/Epcot. IMO, most quiet pools are a bit boring, but we found the one at BWK very nice with landscaping. Again though, that was some time ago.
2. The current room decor posted on the Disney website for BWK is the old decor, but otherwise if you are torn, you could consider which decor appeals to you. You also might want to consider which non-CL dining options appeal to you- if any. It is always easy to dine at your home resort.
3. One other consideration perhaps is that the BWK ends to be slightly noisier at night if you are a very light sleeper. We never had any problem. YC tends to be slightly less kids than BC.
Of the ones you list, you probably won't be able to readily watch any fireworks from your room or the lounge. (some CL resorts do have views of the fireworks, but not the 3 you list.)
Of the ones you list....It is close. I slightly prefer BC/YC over BWK.
