Hmmm... what do you want in your resort? We are not rope drop people. We sleep in, hang out & wander to the parks anytime after 10am. We also like better dining (cloth napkins please

). That said....
We loved AKL. Couldn't beat having coffee on the balcony each morning & watching the animals

. Food options there are pretty good too, but you are pretty far out from most parks.
Boardwalk & the Swan we liked too. Loved being that close to Epcot & all the activities & options on the boardwalk. And the Swan had the quietest hotel room I've ever stayed in!!

For someone like me who has a tough time sleeping that is a huge plus!
Carribean Beach is the only moderate on our 'return to' list of resorts. We hung out one day & napped in the beach hammocks. The main pool bar was nice too. We had a great bartender & met some nice folks there to hang out with one evening. Another evening we sat out in a smoking area while DH had a cigar & we shared a bottle of wine. From where we sat we could look out over the water & had a lovely, romantic evening.
As for pools - the Poly has a nice one. Bar right there, towel service, & they also have cabannas/chairs on the beach. Hard to beat swimming in the pool with a view of the MK. (That said the Poly didn't impress us. Seemed old & worn.)
Carribean Beach the main pool was a zoo

, but the quiet pool near our room was nice. Clean, quiet & plenty of chairs. We brought a cooler from our room with us for beverages so we didn't have to run back & forth. Only down side is you had to go to the main pool for towels or bring from your room, the quiet pool didn't have towels there.
We've not been, but Evidently Beach/Yacht club has the best pool on property. So much so they actively monitor who is there to keep it to resort guests only. I know most resorts say no pool hopping, but I've never seen them check.