As you will hear as many positive remarks as negative remarks about just about all of the resorts, I firmly believe you should go with your gut feelings and stay where it appeals to you. Things can and do go wrong for people at all the resorts, so there will be negative remarks about places others rave about.
We want to eventually say we've tried all the resorts. Some we return to time and again, like the BWI. Others, we will not go back to.
We had a less than stellar stay at CBR. Some things were just chance/bad luck. CRO made an error when we called to shorten our stay. They should have simply modified the existing ressie but instead they re-made a new one. They did something to the ressie that made my preferred location room change to a preferred view room. Don't want to go on too long about this again, but believe me, with an elderly parent along, I really wanted that preferred location. At check in, they were not friendly or accomodating in the least. It was hard for her to climb the stairs too to our room every time we left it. (they said there were no first floor rooms) I think the fact that I was worried about my mom was the worst part. The lack of maid service (had to call and request them to show up at the end of each day) and shabby room only added to it.
But, like I said, so many people here have had wonderful stays there and can't believe the conditions we were subjected to while there. The problems we had could happen at any resort. But because they happened at CBR, we didn't like it there.