We had a great meal at Shutters, but it wasn't crowded at all, so maybe the chefs could focus on cooking ? To answer your question, the burgers were not bad, the pizza was pretty good. But my favorite was the Cesar salad. It is set up like a food court, so you can pick and choose. DH liked the grilled chicken sandwich.
I liked the chicken breast nuggets, but those are the same at any CS place you would go to. My husband LOVED the sandwich of the day - sorry I can't remember what it was called all I remember was it was the same sandwich for the whole week and a half we were there !