We were told the same thing this past Feb. We were down there with our 3 y/o GS. He eats very little and actually had only a few bites that meal (we're talking two bites of broccoli, maybe two noodles, and a bite or two of ice cream--that's it--no meats, no salad, no wontons, no chicken wings, nothing). We asked if we could get a small take out container to put a little of the bread pudding in for him to eat later and was told that since it is an all you can eat meal, that they could not. She even mentioned how little he ate, but still charged us a dining credit and refused to let us carry him anything out. We had to leave it sitting on the table, then got him something later back at the resort.