I agree. This is a very subjective question.
We have been to Disney 10 times. We've stayed at POR, POFQ, Poly, WL, SoG, CB and ASMu. The only reason we stayed at ASMu was because I danced in Disney with my dance studio and we all had to stay at the same resort. This was back in 1999 and it was over Easter so it was super crowded to begin with.
That being said, we ALWAYS use Disney transportation. We like the convenience of it and we've rarely had a problem or had to wait for a long time. The only time we had a problem was at ASMu. Back then (I'm not sure if they still do this) all AS buses went to all three resorts. There was not a specific bus for ASMu, ASMo and ASSp, all buses went to all three. Because of this, the lines for the buses at the end of the night was always super long and I always felt like we spent a lot of wasted time waiting for a bus. This could have been because it was Easter, IDK. Sometimes I still walk by the AS bus waiting area, see a long line and think, "MAN I'm glad I'm not staying there." Also, since our rooms were so far back in the resort, it was quicker to walk through the parking lot to get to ASMo to catch the bus there.
Now this was totally my experience and I hope you have a better one. Things could have changed since I stayed there. IMO, I would rather spring for a moderate than a value.
But on the flip side, I always read how bad the buses were at AKL but we didn't have a problem in Feb. Never had to wait more than 15 min for a bus. This could have been because it was a slower time as it was Feb but who knows. Everyone has a different experience so take it with a grain of salt!
Enjoy Disney!!!
