Ok...I have been following your thread (s)....being reminded of how it is so difficult to choose that one resort...that is going to be magical and make your stay that much better.
I enjoy your enthusiasm...but here is my two cents....you can throw it back too if you'd like
Do research....there is a wealth of info here on threads....thats what I did...I found it easier to read about people's experiences at various resorts....the good , bad and indifferent. Of course....I was up many a night deep into loonngg threads.
Keep in mind....a resort can be a GREAT resort, however, if a person had a negative experience there, the chances are their view of the resort may change. As oppoed to someone who had a great time there.
Everyone has an OPINION based upon THEIR own EXPERIENCE

Which may end up being totally different than yours!
I am guilty of changing resort, room types etc.....after I have booked....so hopefully with your planning, you wont fall into that....resort changing..lol
Good luck in deciding

What is important to you..location...cost...amenities...? You cant go wrong, there is something at WDW for everyone!
As far as this thread is concerned....I preferred being on the yacht Club side better, more peaceful to me....although loved this area..and wont be at Boardwalk til next week!