you'll get votes for both sides

, so the look at what matters to you
towncar pros:
~ avoids possibility of having to wait for bus
~ can make a grocery stop
~ "private" ride
~ no stops at other resorts
~ no waiting for luggage (it can take up to a few hours for luggage to arrive with ME)
ME pros:
~ free
~ go directly to ME after deplaning (no waiting for luggage or lugging it through airport)
~ "coach" buses with cute disney "infomercials"
~ luggage delivered directly to room (& you don't have to wait around for it)
(btw, ME return trip is booked for 3 hours prior to your flight, but you can book a later bus if available)
everyone is welcome to add to the lists
our preference is ME. we do rent a car at the Dolphin for groceries & outlet runs, but take ME for its "fun factor" & convenience (love checking our luggage at our home airport, & not having to deal with it until it *magically* appears in our room). its not even the money: we could save quite a bit by renting a car at MCO, but ME has us hooked
hth