Every region of the country is different. Many religions have their own customs.
A good, Southern, protestant wedding would never have alcohol or a money dance, but that doesn't mean Catholics are going to stop having open or cash bars at their receptions and cultures that shower the bride with cash during that dance will stop.
Different strokes for different folks. And if this type of shower means you aren't bringing a gift, and the bride gets cash instead of stuff she may not like / want / need, what's the harm? These days, esp, the bride and groom may need cash for rent a lot more than they need another place setting of china they'll never use.![]()
I just asked a question - I don't quite understand what it is. I don't think it would be considered a "shower" if people weren't bringing gifts. I'm assuming this is an extra thing?