We did the Barcelona pre cruise
ABD in 2014 with Dusty and James. Loved it. There's no way, with a 15 and 7 year old in tow, that we could have done half of what the ABD did for us. The trip to Monserrat was especially worth it. Orr decision came down to the following:
1. We knew nothing of Barcelona, and ABD would take care of piddly details like a decent hotel, transportation from the airport, transportation to the ship, etc . . .
2. We wouldn't be likely to get stuck somewhere bad or boring, whether at a hotel, restaurant or attraction.
3. We would have a group of friends ready-made before getting on the ship.
4. Barcelona was too great of a city to do a lousy job of it.
5. We opted not to do the on ship ABD, so this was a nice add on that wouldn't break the budget.
Basically, once you pay for flights and the cruise itself, we decided to splurge on this one luxury to make the most of the trip. Well worth it.