Baking question

marydmjj

DIS Veteran
Joined
Sep 24, 2002
Messages
1,367
I'm going to attempt Christmas cookies this week. I have everything planned and need to get the supplies. If a recipe calls for butter but doesn't specify salted or unsalted, what should I use??? I so don't cook or bake...
 
I was always told to use salted for anything that calls for butter unless the recipe specifically says unsalted.
 
In that case I don't think it matters. Generally if unsalted is required they specify.

Even if it's not an ingredient in your recipes, if you're making sugar cookies or other rolled cookies I recommend buying some confectionary sugar and mixing 1/4 with the flour you use for rolling. It helps keep the bottoms of the cookies from tasting floury.
 
Unless otherwise specified, I always use salted butter.
 

One of my favorite baking books says to always use unsalted butter when baking sweets. I do use lightly salted when it doesnt specify because thats what I usually have on hand.
 
I use salted butter even if the recipe says unsalted. I've never ruined anything yet.
 
/
In that case I don't think it matters. Generally if unsalted is required they specify.

Even if it's not an ingredient in your recipes, if you're making sugar cookies or other rolled cookies I recommend buying some confectionary sugar and mixing 1/4 with the flour you use for rolling. It helps keep the bottoms of the cookies from tasting floury.

That is a great idea!:thumbsup2 I'll have to remember that for next week when I'm making sugar cookies.
 
As a professional chef, never use salted butter in your recipes as if the recipe calls for salt, you would put that in seperately.

Bakers always use unsalted butter.
 
I almost always use salted for cookies when they have chocolate in them ....but I know that you are supposed to use unsalted for baking so that you have more control of the salt content.
 
In that case I don't think it matters. Generally if unsalted is required they specify.

Even if it's not an ingredient in your recipes, if you're making sugar cookies or other rolled cookies I recommend buying some confectionary sugar and mixing 1/4 with the flour you use for rolling. It helps keep the bottoms of the cookies from tasting floury.

I wholeheartedly agree with the sugar in the flour for rolling your cookies. It makes such a difference. I do the same with my gingerbread as well, only I add spices to the flour.

Linda
 
I bake cookies every week....always use salted. They always come out great.
 
We have always used unsalted butter when we bake. In fact we stock up and freeze it throughout the year when we see it on sale for baking around the holidays.

Thaks so much for the tip about the confectioner's sugar when rolling out cookies. I will have to try that when I make mine this weekend.
 
Since you're asking, you should always use unsalted butter when baking. Since it is a special occasion, I would suggest using a high quality unsalted butter like Plugra or Lurpak if you can find it.
 
I just want to say: thumbs up for the baking! I think the last time I turned on my oven was in 2007 - I am impressed! :)
 
I always use unsalted butter for everything. Especially if salt is an additional ingredient in the recipe.
 





New Posts










Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top