Karen - I have yet to read a single negative comment about romeinlimo on either the DIS or on Cruise Critic!! That's why we booked them for both Rome & Naples...they offer a 50 euro discount for booking in more than 1 port too!! They are extremely pricey for just the 3 of us but I felt the price was comparable to what we would've spent with
DCL for similar itineraries. I had hoped there would be more peeps interested in sharing but that didn't materialize so I booked them anyway to be sure to grab a spot. We booked the "Highlights of Rome" and "Pompeii, Sorrento & Positano" plus the private guides for the Coliseum, the Vatican and Pompeii. It works out to be 1200 euro or currently about $1,700 USD. I worked out that DCL was going to run us $987 for the Best of Rome and $537 for Pompeii & the Amalfi Coast. So it is not necessarily going to be a lot cheaper BUT it will be more customized & certainly more private than a bus tour. We can go at our own pace, eat wherever we want, pee whenever we want and probably see more in less time than with DCL.
I am a little bummed tho as the conversion rate between the dollar & the euro keeps getting worse!! It is higher today than ever.

romeinlimo gave me the option to pay in full by credit card by the end of March rather than to wait & pay in cash or via travelers checks in August. I was thinking about doing this so we could save on how much cash we'll need to have on us later... but I just looked at the rate & the darned thing has gone up so much that everything that I haven't already paid in full is going to cost us sooo much more!! This bill for romeinlimo alone is running somewhere between $50-100 more than it WAS just a few weeks ago when I booked them!! I am glad I paid the Novotel's non-refundable rate too - our room has gone up from $146 to $154 with the higher rate!! Now I wish I'd gone ahead & paid for the Hotel Jazz & our other hotel in Paris up front. (The DLP pkg. is paid in full as were the transfers that I booked in Paris so those are safe.) I suppose it's all a gamble as to whether the conversion rate will drop back any more or not before March 31?! It seems that lately it only goes UP! Grrrrrrr! It's like buying airfare!!!
(PS) Did you see that DCL offers a private boat charter for Naples for a mere $5,500?!