We are planning for the week before Thanksgiving, coming home on that Monday, I would never leave any of my children alone on a holiday.
Same question to you as I have for the OP...... what is it that you expect your son to do for Thanksgiving?
That said though, I would not leave him over Thanksgiving.
For the record, I would never tell him that I couldn't afford to take him, if he really wants to go and can take the time from classes than I will spend the extra money and gladly bring him.
I can't imagine missing 7 days of college (or even high school)! Dd18 knows that there might be vacations she's excluded from, simply because of her school schedule, and she's fine with it. She certainly would not be okay with missing more than a week of school - who does that?
I can't possibly believe he would be able to miss 7+ days of college. It is virtually impossible.
For our children, school is their job. We had no choice with our oldest as his college major highly recommends that the students not work at all and they definitely cannot work more than 10 hours a week. Not much money you can save up with only 10 hours a week.
But even if they didn't have those restrictions at school, I had children because I wanted them. That didn't end at 18. If I am planning on a vacation, my kids are invited and it is on my dime. Now, they do offer to help out on their own, but I would never invoice my own kids for a family vacation.
Same question to you as I have for the OP...... what is it that you expect your son to do for Thanksgiving?
I would be heartbroken to tell my son we wouldn't be here for him to come home to on Thanksgiving. That first year away is hard for some kids. I was terribly homesick by Thanksgiving that year. I can't even imagine having my family somewhere else.
So here's a monkey wrench that I'll throw in there to everyone that's saying it's all or nothing, my DS 13 has special needs, he will be with my DH and myself his whole life. Since he will be always vacationing with us, do we always invite our other children and their spouses and children to come? And since we will be paying for our special needs DS, does that mean we will be paying for everyone else's too?
I cannot fathom telling my 20 y/o college student (who does NOT live at home) that we couldn't afford to take him on our family vacation. We plan our trips around everyones schedule, including his. Maybe when he gets married we can revisit it, but I want him with us for as long as I can get him.
Thank you to those of you who suggested him flying separately and just joining us for a few days. Not sure why I had not thought of that! I think the main reason that he would want to go is for Universal, we haven't been since HP has been there and I know he wants to do that. I could plan for us to go there when he's there so he won't miss out
I think every family is different.
As evidenced in this thread, many parents continue to pay for their children (& their children's families) vacations for many years & long after the children have "left home" - from the entire vacation to parts of the vacation. Different things work for different families & different family dynamics.
But, no, I don't think you necessarily need to pay for your adult children's (& their future spouses' & future children's) vacations even though you'll continue to pay for your special needs child after he reaches adulthood. And I don't think your children would expect you to.
However, at this particular time, I think your 19 (almost 20) year old son is still part of your immediate family unit.
Even though he is living away at college, he probably still considers your home to be his home, his primary residence. He's not "on his own" yet & hasn't established his home & his life yet away from you & your DH & his siblings.
You are planning a family vacation & are taking your other children. I'd have a very hard time not inviting him.
That said, I'm not sure how a college student could miss that many days, so, if I were set on going during a time when he was in school & couldn't change my schedule for a better time for him, I'd give him the option of flying down & joining us for a couple of days.
Bottom line, I'd want him to still feel included w/ his family.
I would look at it differently if he were 30 years old & still living in your basement.
Like I said earlier, I want to enjoy family vacations & the time together w/ all 3 of our children for as long as I can.
I have a 27 year old daughter with Down syndrome.So here's a monkey wrench that I'll throw in there to everyone that's saying it's all or nothing, my DS 13 has special needs, he will be with my DH and myself his whole life. Since he will be always vacationing with us, do we always invite our other children and their spouses and children to come? And since we will be paying for our special needs DS, does that mean we will be paying for everyone else's too?
Well since my DS had to be at our house this Thanksgiving when I hosted my family and he complained the whole time and said my food was not good and that he would have had better at his GF's, I told him he could go to Thanksgiving at his GF's next time...so he already has plans. He will be living at home, working and going to community college. He will be busy all week.
My DH and I are discussing a November trip to WDW, we have 4 children, ages at the time of trip will be 20, 13, 11 and 9. We have decided to go in November because we really want to see all of the Christmas decorations and this is the first time my DH will be able to get away from work at that time of year. DS 19 will be in school, DH and I kinda assumed that he would not be going with us this year. My DS asked me the other day if we were taking a trip this year and I told him that we were thinking November, I think he assumes that he will be going. I didn't have the heart to tell him that we weren't planning on him going because we figured he'd have school. Also by him not going we will be saving a lot, in airfare, tickets and food. I hate to sound cheap and say we aren't bringing him because of the cost but realistically, it does come into play. We are all going to the Outer Banks this summer so it's not like he will never vacation with us again. DH and I both were talking about it and said that our parents went on vacations all of the time when we were in college but we didn't have younger siblings going with them so it's a little different. So my question is, do we suck it up, allow him to miss school and go with us or do we figure a way to nicely tell him that we weren't planning on him going? I hate to make him left out of the loop so my mom guilt is kicking in overdrive
My DH and I are discussing a November trip to WDW, we have 4 children, ages at the time of trip will be 20, 13, 11 and 9. We have decided to go in November because we really want to see all of the Christmas decorations and this is the first time my DH will be able to get away from work at that time of year. DS 19 will be in school, DH and I kinda assumed that he would not be going with us this year. My DS asked me the other day if we were taking a trip this year and I told him that we were thinking November, I think he assumes that he will be going. I didn't have the heart to tell him that we weren't planning on him going because we figured he'd have school. Also by him not going we will be saving a lot, in airfare, tickets and food. I hate to sound cheap and say we aren't bringing him because of the cost but realistically, it does come into play. We are all going to the Outer Banks this summer so it's not like he will never vacation with us again. DH and I both were talking about it and said that our parents went on vacations all of the time when we were in college but we didn't have younger siblings going with them so it's a little different. So my question is, do we suck it up, allow him to miss school and go with us or do we figure a way to nicely tell him that we weren't planning on him going? I hate to make him left out of the loop so my mom guilt is kicking in overdrive