Well, it looks like you're used to WDW deluxe resorts. I, on the other hand, am usually relegated to the budget-type hotels due to budget constraints--LOL!! That said, we felt as if we were living in the lap of luxury! But the HGVC is probably somewhere between a moderate and upscale resort. Our particular unit was roomy and clean--the kitchen was newer and the appliances were in good condition, including the washer/dryer. We had a large jacuzzi tub in the master bedroom.
We would stay there again in a heartbeat if we could get the deal we got last year...anyway, hopefully someone who has stayed in other deluxe resorts and HGVC will post and give you a better comparison.