Any one been on every cruise ship?

[tidefan]

We have been on all 5, and like all 5, but if I had to rank them I would put:

1. Magic - Just our favorite, feels like home
2. Fantasy - A close second
3. Wonder
4. Dream
5. Wish

 

[JM_97]

Pass the orange. Maybe it was on Disney. Along with Match Your Mate. But other cruise lines push it to more R-rated comedians and activities.

I tend to blur my memory of things I don’t appreciate.

Disney has pushed the envelope in the adult spaces before.

 

[Lillebelle]

In my heart of hearts the Magic/Wonder are my favorites, partly due to familiarity/nostalgia, partly because they are the easiest to navigate and have that more intimate feel. Love the Rapunzel restaurant especially, and I like the small ship version of Animator's over the Dream/Fantasy. Dream/Fantasy have more to do but somehow I never manage to do most of them so I'm not convinced that matters. And there are things I like about the Wish but man, I did miss that full circle walking track when I was on the Wish. It's not like I'm an exercise fanatic or anything, I just like being able to go out in the evening and walk around the deck a few times when it's quiet and peaceful. I tried to do it on the Wish and just got mad that the stairs to the forward section were locked.

 

[DCLMP]

Yes all of them multiple times. It's hard to say which is a favorite. I'm big on itinerary. Not a huge fan of the Dream, but our European cruise on the Dream last year was pretty nice. Service was awful so not as good as the Magic in Europe the Year before. The Magic, Wonder and Fantasy have always been pretty solid. The Dream is meh and the Wish I didn't like, but willing to give it another try if prices come down.

Given that I've been cruising on for DCL for a while the Magic and Wonder have been the most memorable, but a lot of that is because they go to the best places, Alaska, Eastern Canada, Europe, Panama, Hawaii and now Australia.

 

[dkis4nu]

We’ve been on all 5, but like the Dream/Fantasy the most because of the adult areas & crew. The Wish we did not care for, as we got the feeling the adult areas were afterthoughts. But enjoy whatever ship you choose-as they say “a bad day on a Disney ship is better than a good day any where else”

dk

 

[Henlady]

We have been on all tive for a total of 16 cruises - Wonder 3, Magic 4 (#5 in August), Dream 4, Fabtasy 3, Wish 2. We do tend to prefer the Magic and Dream. The Wish was nice, best food of all the ships but layout seemed very congested overall. The adult pool area was not good at all for us.

 

[emmabelle]

I've been on all five and although I'll be in the minority, I really liked the Wish. The only thing I didn't like was the adult pool being people soup.

 

[Akck]

Been on all 5 and the Wonder is a favorite. While the Wish is different, I didn’t think it was all that bad.

 

[Trera]

All five are great. We like each ship for a different reason but we now only travel in concierge and used to always feel like our love of the ships centered around that service. As concierge hosts would move around to different ships, we tended to sometimes follow them to their new ship. We really had some of our best cruises with Glen and G over the years on the Wonder. Danny on the Dream. Julia, Michelle and Andy on the Magic.

 

[sponica]

I've only been on the Dream and the Wish. The dream was on my honeymoon so I don't remember it, well I remember our bar bill when we disembarked. It could be that in the 10 years between cruises, it was just easier to learn where everything was ahead of time for our trip on the Wish. (Although for some reason my brain would always get disoriented trying to get to the splashpad on the wish).

We never made it to the District on the Dream, I don't like being indoors unless I really have to be because I don't get nice weather that much during the year, so we lived on the pool deck.

 

[tidefan]

We have been on all tive for a total of 16 cruises - Wonder 3, Magic 4 (#5 in August), Dream 4, Fabtasy 3, Wish 2. We do tend to prefer the Magic and Dream. The Wish was nice, best food of all the ships but layout seemed very congested overall. The adult pool area was not good at all for us.

Which cruise? We are on the Magic in August as well!

 

[bbn1122]

I am about to sail on my 10th cruise next week on The Wish for the 2nd time. I think that's my favorite ship. I love how special she is....she is goregous. I love the adult areas spread out instead of a dark hallway. I am not crazy about the dinner shows, I loved 1923. The Adult area, I love the location, no kiddies will mistakenly walk thru that area. The pool, I like how it cascaded off the back of ship, the views are beautiful up there. Hopefully, on the Treasure they take a little care to twik how you get in the pool. (Accessibility). I like how easy it is to get on the AquaMouse, no climbing stairs.

I have sailed on the Magic 5 times and the Dream 3. I love both these ships for different reasons. I prefer the Magics pool layout over the Dreams. I love the Satelittle Falls area on the Dream and the AquaDuck!!!

I almost booked the Fantasy for my cruise in February 2025, but the price for Concierge was better on the Dream. I am looking forward to experiencing the new Island, Lighthouse Point, on Lookout Cay ( is that the right name )

Now, my view is from an adult womens perspective, who has been sailing with no kiddos, just DH.

Happy sailing to everyone!

 

[Flip flops in winter]

Yes, we've been on all the ships at least once, some twice and are booked for the Treasure. My only complaints about the Wish all boil down to the crowds and the very short itineraries, which pretty much go hand and hand. With that being said, we sailed the Magic in the Med so it has a very special place in my heart. But they are all wonderful!

 

[Henlady]

Which cruise? We are on the Magic in August as well!

August 12-17

 

[tidefan]

August 12-17

See you onboard!

 

[Henlady]

See you onboard!

It looks like it’s going to be a fairly full sailing. Can’t wait

 

[CarolinaBlue]

I've been on all of them, but it's been a few years since I've sailed on the Magic and Dream. We've been sailing the Fantasy since 2012 because it's our favorite. Just got back from the Alaska cruise on the Wonder (first time on the Wonder since 2010). There are things I like about each one, but the Fantasy is definitely my favorite.

 

[Lorana]

I've been on all 5 so far, and will add the Treasure to our roster in February. Dream/Fantasy are our favorites, and it's hard to say between the Magic and Wish for next as we like them for different reasons. If our kids were still kids, I think Wish, just for the those kids clubs decks, but we really like the smaller size of the Magic.

I haven't been on the Wonder since our Honeymoon back in 2001, so we haven't experienced it since it's refurb. We were supposed to sail on it again in 2020, but then covid happened, and so that didn't happen.

 

[meremac]

I've been on all five (some multiple times). It's really a matter of taste, but I prefer the Magic/Wonder over the Dream/Fantasy. I just really enjoy the more intimate feel of the smaller ships. And then (and I know this is not the most popular opinion), I would put the Wish right in the middle. Maybe it's because, even though the Wish is the biggest ship, it feels more intimate to me with the scattered smaller bars/lounges/spaces. And the Wish's Grand Hall is just so stunning ~ there's nothing like walking into that when you first board IMO. But as others have said, my fav ship is ultimately always the one that I'm on at the moment !

 

[auntlynne]

@bbn1122 Lookout Cay at Lighthouse Point.

You had all the parts.