I agree, the Harborside has always looked nice. We go to the MV every year but we haven't stayed there yet. Friends of ours have and liked it. We have stayed at many other Inns/hotels there and have rented houses. Harborview has a great location in Edgartown center for shopping, browsing, eating, etc. There is a pool at the resort but not a beach (closest would probably be South beach and you would need to drive - the public trolley might go there as well). MV is a great place but extremely crowded in the summer and you need ferry reservations (if taking your car). We prefer to go in June or September to avoid the excessive crowds. Good luck with your decision.