I didn't even bother to haggle this time. I said cancel at the prompt, told the agent I want to renew at my current offer (the $25/5 months) and he took care of it in about 5 minutes. He reminded me to call back right before it renews so I can continue at the same price. My kids were stunned I didn't have to say VERY EXPENSIVE about 3 times while I was on the phone, which seems to trigger the lower price deal for me. LOLOLOLOL