Amish Cheesecake?

happily single

Left foot first!
Joined
Jan 12, 2008
Messages
3,625
So my SO has decided for Christmas all he wants is a homemade cheesecake, from me. He often raves about cheesecakes that he's had in Amish country. He says that the graham cracker crust is 3 inches deep. I should add he owns and prepares every single dish at a very popular resturant, so he knows his way around food.

I did make him a cheesecake in the spring which was a big hit, but it was a white chocolate one and no matter what I did I could not get the crust to be super deep. He wants a "plain vanilla cheesecake" this time.

Help a girl out with your best cheesecake recipes!
 
3” thick graham cracker crust? That’s sounds strange. Maybe he meant it was made in a springform pan and the crust was all the way up the sides which would probably be about 3”. It would look like that once out of the pan.
 

I can't imagine any reason to have a 3" bottom crust. I assume they are referring to pressing the crumbs up the side of the pan and the 3" refers to the vertical dimension. For the typical cheesecake I make using a 9" cake pan, the basic ingredients are 2- 8oz packages of cream cheese, 2 eggs and 1 pint of sour cream. For a less dense texture, whip the eggs whites separately from the other ingredients then gently fold into the batter. Bake at 300 for about 1 hour. Cheesecakes are a baked custard, so baking at too high a temperature is what causes cracking. I get the best results baking it longer at a lower temp. Water bath insures a more even distribution of the heat during baking. I like using a cake pan since you can place it in a water bath without worrying about the water seeping into the pan and ruining the cheesecake. When done baking, let it completely cool then invert out of the pan. Turn over a second time so the crust is on the bottom. Every oven cools at a different temperature. Recipes that suggest finishing the baking with oven door open or oven turned off may not work for you depending on the type of oven you have. Some of the newer recipes suggest a desired internal temperature which is a far more accurate/consistent way to get repeatable results.

Even if you line the outside of a springform pan with foil, it only takes a pinhole size leak to ruin it. Cake pans work much better and yield more consistent results.

There are lots of cheesecake recipes online and I find it best to check the RATIO of certain key ingredients such as cream cheese/eggs/sour cream/sugar. Typically, you will find most cheesecake recipes use 1 block of cream cheese for every egg. Other flavorings such as white chocolate, vanilla extract, etc. are used depending the specific flavor you are looking for. Some recipes call for a 10" pan which is HUGE and nearly twice the volume of a 9" pan.

I also have never heard of an Amish cheesecake, but perhaps you can search around online for a recipe.
 
I’ll be honest. Never had an Amish cheesecake and never heard of one. I say this with the idea of Jewish, French, Basque or Italian style cheesecakes thus can’t direct you towards any. Oh and I’ve never eaten at a Cheesecake Factory so if it can be found there I still wouldn’t know. Sorry but best of luck and you are surrounded by many knowledgeable posters!
 
3" crust? I'll be honest I've never heard of that....and I've lived in an Amish area/community!
I will ask tomorrow for him to clarify, but I really understood him wanting a lot of graham crackers. Looking at a ruler three inches is a Lot!
 
I like cheesecake with a crunchy crust. Too often the crust is soggy. I'm looking for a good recipe too.
 
I looked around online and found 3 totally different recipes for 'Amish cheesecake'. Will have to wait for the OP to return to get more info about their particular version.
 
I make what is considered a traditional New York style cheesecake. It's in a springform pan and I make the bottom crust pretty thick (but not nearly 3 inches but it may have the appearance of going up the side an inch or two depending on my patience. The cheesecake recipe itself has about 4 blocks of Philadelphia Cream Cheese in it (no other type will do). There's not much more in there to "dilute" it down so it's pretty thick. Other recipes add more liquid so it's a looser cheesecake. I prefer a "dry" cheesecake. I looked up one receipe of an Amish cheesecake and it didn't have a lot of cream cheese in it nor much of a crust so I'm not sure what your husband is seeking, lol!! Could be someone at an Amish market made a traditional cheesecake?
 
Could be someone at an Amish market made a traditional cheesecake?
While possible- and I hate to burst anyone’s bubble- many of the cheesecakes sold at ‘Amish Markets’ aren’t actually made by them (along w/ other items although for sure some items are).
Not that they aren’t good, they are. I’ve bought many :)!!!!!
 
I make what is considered a traditional New York style cheesecake. It's in a springform pan and I make the bottom crust pretty thick (but not nearly 3 inches but it may have the appearance of going up the side an inch or two depending on my patience. The cheesecake recipe itself has about 4 blocks of Philadelphia Cream Cheese in it (no other type will do). There's not much more in there to "dilute" it down so it's pretty thick. Other recipes add more liquid so it's a looser cheesecake. I prefer a "dry" cheesecake. I looked up one receipe of an Amish cheesecake and it didn't have a lot of cream cheese in it nor much of a crust so I'm not sure what your husband is seeking, lol!! Could be someone at an Amish market made a traditional cheesecake?
Similar to this >>>

FOR THE FILLING​

  • 32 oz (four 8-oz blocks) cream cheese, at room temperature
  • 2 cups sugar
  • 3 tablespoons all-purpose flour
  • 4 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 1 teaspoon packed lemon zest, from 1 lemon
  • 2 teaspoons fresh lemon juice, from 1 lemon
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 6 large eggs
  • ½ cup sour cream
  • Special equipment: 9- or 10-inch springform pan; 18-inch heavy-duty aluminum foil
r.e. bold -- if it isn't heavier than a bar of gold, it ain't N.Y. Style Cheesecake :teeth:
 
This is the New York or Jewish style cheesecake I compare the competition to:

https://secretnyc.co/juniors-cheesecake-recipe/

When the owner of Junior’s died, his New York Times obituary was printed and included the recipe for his cheesecake. We loved his output and he returned the favor 😀
Thanks for this!! I love getting the mini ones at Costco for the holidays but I’d love to make it fresh at home.
 
Similar to this >>>

FOR THE FILLING​

  • 32 oz (four 8-oz blocks) cream cheese, at room temperature
  • 2 cups sugar
  • 3 tablespoons all-purpose flour
  • 4 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 1 teaspoon packed lemon zest, from 1 lemon
  • 2 teaspoons fresh lemon juice, from 1 lemon
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 6 large eggs
  • ½ cup sour cream
  • Special equipment: 9- or 10-inch springform pan; 18-inch heavy-duty aluminum foil
r.e. bold -- if it isn't heavier than a bar of gold, it ain't N.Y. Style Cheesecake :teeth:
Yes, this is very similar, if not identical, to what I make.
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE







New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top