American Idol Top 20 Season 9

[mandy200587]

careful Mandy... Andrew amy read this....

Good point. At least it would be amusing, I would love to see Lee do it. He redid Beautiful People by Marilyn Manson why not some Rihanna.

 

[DarthKTrava]

More like a talent puddle.

Not even big enough to have tadpoles in them.

 

[DarthKTrava]

Girl, he doesn't qualify to be Hootie. He can be the Blowfish.

 

[Robinrs]

Girl, he doesn't qualify to be Hootie. He can be the Blowfish.

OmG, Amen!!!!

Great list, and for once I know EVERY ONE of them. My favorite is At Your Best by Aaliyah. I met her one month before she died. I named my cat after her.... Such a loss!

Mike will probably do Luther... ... come on he's done James Brown, Maxwell and Otis Redding, it's time to do Luther. I .. can't .. wait...

Tim should bust a move and do Bobby Brown's "My Prerogative"

Lee has GOT to do "Mustang Sally"

Casey could handle "Hold On I'm Coming"

Siobhan should do "Chain of Fools"

Crystal should do Ray Charles, I'd LOVE to hear her sing "Unchain My Heart"

Aaron should do Michael Jackson

Gang Boy, DiDi and Katie.... I could care less...

 

[agnes!]

...2 - I'm not sure about Joe Jonas or Miley but I do think that Demi would have made it through if she auditioned for American Idol. She does have true talent.

I saw her in concert in 2008 when she was on tour with the Jonas Brothers. She was PHENOMENAL and BLEW Avril Lavigne (the other performer on that tour) away. Amazing performance.

agnes!

 

[ShuisFan584]

Hey all! I didn't get a chance to come online during this weeks Idol. But I have to say that this week sucked as much as the rest. I'm still not loving anyone. This season is bad, but it's still nowhere near as bad as Season 3.

I'm not surprised that Paige went home, but I still think that there were many others who could have gone before her. Andrew and Didi are annoying me more and more each week and I don't know how they haven't been in the bottom yet.

I think Crystal has the best voice out of anyone but she's starting to get boring because all her performances seem the same. I think Siobhan is probably my favorite right now but even she seems like she tries too hard sometimes.

 

[mandy200587]

Interesting interview with Paige, kinda of snarky comments to the judges.

http://www.eonline.com/uberblog/wat...itterfeed&utm_campaign=twitterfeed_topstories

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

I would love to see one of the guys take Umbrella and make that acoustic, because some of the versions I've heard have been cool.

Mandy Moore did a REALLY awesome version of Umbrella, and she actually slowed it down but it sounded really good.

 

[mandy200587]

Mandy Moore did a REALLY awesome version of Umbrella, and she actually slowed it down but it sounded really good.

I remember that version! There have been some awesome covers of it.

 

[cruiserkaren]

Hey all! I didn't get a chance to come online during this weeks Idol. But I have to say that this week sucked as much as the rest. I'm still not loving anyone. This season is bad, but it's still nowhere near as bad as Season 3.

I'm not surprised that Paige went home, but I still think that there were many others who could have gone before her. Andrew and Didi are annoying me more and more each week and I don't know how they haven't been in the bottom yet.

I think Crystal has the best voice out of anyone but she's starting to get boring because all her performances seem the same. I think Siobhan is probably my favorite right now but even she seems like she tries too hard sometimes.

I know season 3 was Fantasia but I don't remember anyone else or if there was someone I liked. I don't remember hating it as much as this season. I'll look to see who else was that season. (Although the fact that I don't remember anyone but the winner isn't a good sign.)

 

[Simba's Mom]

This is my first time here (I usually wait til there are only about 6 left before watching), but I did see Paige the other night. And I'm sorry, but I can't believe she was surprised at being eliminated. Anyone can get sick, laryngitis, whatever, sorry-she was horrible! I think the other one who wasn't his best was Tim, but he was 1000 times better than Paige.

 

[kimmar067]

OmG, Amen!!!!

Great list, and for once I know EVERY ONE of them. My favorite is At Your Best by Aaliyah. I met her one month before she died. I named my cat after her.... Such a loss!

Mike will probably do Luther... ... come on he's done James Brown, Maxwell and Otis Redding, it's time to do Luther. I .. can't .. wait...

Tim should bust a move and do Bobby Brown's "My Prerogative"

Lee has GOT to do "Mustang Sally"

Casey could handle "Hold On I'm Coming"

Siobhan should do "Chain of Fools"

Crystal should do Ray Charles, I'd LOVE to hear her sing "Unchain My Heart"

Aaron should do Michael Jackson

Gang Boy, DiDi and Katie.... I could care less...

...as long as she doesn't SCREAM again....it's getting played out...

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

OmG, Amen!!!!

Great list, and for once I know EVERY ONE of them. My favorite is At Your Best by Aaliyah. I met her one month before she died. I named my cat after her.... Such a loss!

Mike will probably do Luther... ... come on he's done James Brown, Maxwell and Otis Redding, it's time to do Luther. I .. can't .. wait...

Tim should bust a move and do Bobby Brown's "My Prerogative"

Lee has GOT to do "Mustang Sally"

Casey could handle "Hold On I'm Coming"

Siobhan should do "Chain of Fools"

Crystal should do Ray Charles, I'd LOVE to hear her sing "Unchain My Heart"

Aaron should do Michael Jackson

Gang Boy, DiDi and Katie.... I could care less...

Mike should do something that we're not expecting tho...because i think we're all expecting him to do Luthor and when he finally does it we'll all just be going "yeah....so?" know what i mean??

i'd LOVE to see Tim doing "My Perogative"!!

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

...as long as she doesn't SCREAM again....it's getting played out...

no one called out Lambert on that last season tho. and he screeched at some point during every performance.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

does anyone read or get Entertainment Weekly this week??

they had a whole article on how bad this season is and what should be done to change it.

it says stuff like:


we like that they can play instruments, but everyone is playing them now, and we feel like they're hiding behind the guitar.

ban songs that have already been sung before, so we don't have to hear them butchered over and over again.

try and sing a song WITHOUT changing it up completely, FIRST....then try and do your own cover after we already know you can sing.


get rid of the lip synched group numbers. NO one likes them.

get the mentors there for a whole week, instead of one day.

better theme nights, and stop re-using the same themes over and over again



there was more to it, but those were the main ones that i agreed with.

 

[mandy200587]

Here's the less than fantastic performers for Wednesday!

Usher, Bieber, Diddy with TI and Dirty Money.

I thought this was a family friendly show.

 

[FINFAN]

does anyone read or get Entertainment Weekly this week??

they had a whole article on how bad this season is and what should be done to change it.

it says stuff like:


we like that they can play instruments, but everyone is playing them now, and we feel like they're hiding behind the guitar.

ban songs that have already been sung before, so we don't have to hear them butchered over and over again.

try and sing a song WITHOUT changing it up completely, FIRST....then try and do your own cover after we already know you can sing.


get rid of the lip synched group numbers. NO one likes them.

get the mentors there for a whole week, instead of one day.

better theme nights, and stop re-using the same themes over and over again



there was more to it, but those were the main ones that i agreed with.

My brother and sis in law gave me a subscription for Christmas and I got it in the mail the other day, I'll have to check that article out!

 

[Robinrs]

My brother and sis in law gave me a subscription for Christmas and I got it in the mail the other day, I'll have to check that article out!

I love the title... Tour Of Doodie!! http://www.ew.com/ew/package/0,,20312226,00.html

 

[Nancy]

no one called out Lambert on that last season tho. and he screeched at some point during every performance.

I complained a lot here...I'm sure anyone that was on here last year will back that up.

Here's the less than fantastic performers for Wednesday!

Usher, Bieber, Diddy with TI and Dirty Money.

I thought this was a family friendly show.

Not too crazy about the lineup. Usher..yes...the rest no thank you.

 

[mandy200587]

I complained a lot here...I'm sure anyone that was on here last year will back that up.



Not too crazy about the lineup. Usher..yes...the rest no thank you.

I'll back ya up Nancy. I was on your side.