American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread**

[Divamomto3]

Paula is TOTALLY trashed! HOW does she get away with that??? Ryan looks like he can't stand them tonight.

Sway...like the story about how his parents got together for the first time in years to see him perform. I hate to see him go.
David the crooner...don't think that style will ever be an American Idol, but dang...if I were in high school, I'd be IN LOVE with him!

Speaking of which...I felt like David had a girlfriend among the girl contestants. Do we know of any love rumors among the cast??

 

[disnygoof]

UGH! I missed it!! Can someone tell me who besides Sway and Brenna got voted off?? Purty please? Thanks!

 

[Nancy]

Girls gone: Brenna and Heather...no surprise
Guys gone: David and Sway..again no surprise

 

[tevagirl]

Is she ever not? I think they ought to have her go first from now on--get her rambling BS out of the way quickly before hearing the real comments.

I think they ought to have her go to rehab first.

 

[iluvcountry]

Heather and David also got voted off

 

[Nancy]

Just saw my new tag...I LOVE it! (twitterpatted)


Tonights show was something else. Paula not only sounded out of it but she looked it too. I'm glad Ryan made the comment he did about acting adult. If I was one of those girls standing there when she made her stupid salad and pizza comment I would have smacked her.

Asking the guys if they felt there were in the bottom three...way to put someone on the spot...if they say no, they come across as cocky (Gedeon) if they say yes, they are basically admitting they stunk up the place.

BTW...I loved Carries song...she was my choice all along last year and her CD is really good.

 

[Slacking]

I hated Carrie last season, but love her CD. Weird little cleavage hole in her dress.

Not happy with the results tonight. BUT, I loved the farewell montage. Brenna was clearly the star in the video, and I chuckled everytime she popped up on the video. Cya Brenna

 

[Planogirl]

Good choices on who to vote off tonight IMO. So far the voters seem to be right on.

What is with Paula? I've often defended her but she was so weird tonight. How can she crack jokes when people are standing there waiting for their fate?

 

[Sandy22]

Is Paula drunk

I've never thought so before (despite what others have said) but tonight I seriously thought she was!

 

[cruiserkaren]

What sticks out most tonight is not who got voted off but PAULA! Geez, what is wrong with that woman? Can they not find a judge who's coherent? She is really getting on my nerves! At least Ryan made a few comments. He looked pretty annoyed.

 

[Slacking]

I don't understand why people are suddenly noticing Paula. She has been like that for awhile.

 

[tevagirl]

She looked okay to me this season until tonight.

 

[Nancy]

I don't understand why people are suddenly noticing Paula. She has been like that for awhile.

We all noticed it last year too. I don't remember her being that bad in other seasons. last year she was loopy, this season she is really annoying and looks out of it.

 

[Philadisney]

It's "Bad Day" by Daniel Powter-the video is on Yahoo music-if you're interested-it's a great video, and I agree, I love the song.

thank you! i will go look for it right now!

 

[palmtreegirl]

I don't understand why people are suddenly noticing Paula. She has been like that for awhile.

I've been saying it since Season 2.

 

[palmtreegirl]

so this carrie song, i could do without. sorry, not a fan and never was jesus take her microphone away!

 

[damo]

I've been saying it since Season 2.

She's always more entertaining and contraversial than the contestants!!!

 

[Monte Cristo]

I hated Carrie last season, but love her CD. Weird little cleavage hole in her dress.

Not happy with the results tonight. BUT, I loved the farewell montage. Brenna was clearly the star in the video, and I chuckled everytime she popped up on the video. Cya Brenna

And don't let the door hit you in the rear end on your way out. Thank goodness. I would rather give myself dental surgery than watch another performance by this thing.

 

[Jerseylicious]

I've never thought so before (despite what others have said) but tonight I seriously thought she was!

I said the SAME THING to my husband!!! What's the deal with that? I mean these poor people are SO nervous to begin with!

I can't believe Sway left. He had an AWESOME voice.

I am ECSTATIC Brenna left. She was BEYOND freaking annoying!

I personally love Chris and Taylor. For the girls I like Lisa, I think she has the best voice. Chris ROCKS though, he is awesome and I hope he goes all the way!!

 

[palmtreegirl]

She's always more entertaining and contraversial than the contestants!!!

So true! I wonder if she's hitting on Ace yet?