American Idol, Season 5 **Official Discussion Thread** Part 2

[Obi-Wan Pinobi]

Katherine sounded good, but not as good as Simon made her out to be (in a different league than the others - well, Kellie, yes )

My bottom three for right now until I rewatch some - Kellie, Ace and Paris

 

[bicker]

Well, a bunch of good performances, except for Kellie. Elliott was mediocre. Everyone else was at least very good.

 

[Papa Deuce]

Wow... Kellie was THE WORST tonight. I hate to admit it. But I think she will not be cut.

My favorite 3 tonight in order:

Chris.......
Taylor....
And, dare I say..... Katherine? wow... finally I enjoyed her!

 

[Mickey's sunshine]

thanks Eeyores Buddy Bear.

 

[J.Cooper]

I have to disagree with Simon. I think Paris was a tad better tonight than Katherine. I think the bottom 3 should be Kellie, Ace and Elliott.

 

[Jeanny]

busy signals for my top three... I'll keep trying

 

[Octoberbeauty]

As always... LOVED Katherine and Chris tonight. I thought everyone did well though. Maybe it's because I love this kind of music though.

Go Katherine!!!!!

 

[wdwgirl03]

I have got through 5 straight times for Elliott - he needs votes people!!!

I will definitely be voting for Elliott tonight! So far I haven't gotten through, but I've only called about 5 times.

 

[wdwgirl03]

"If I wish upon a star..." Kellie will be gone...

LOL!! Maybe if we both do it'll happen. I am getting very sick of her...and Paris...

 

[BibbidiBobbidiBOO]

I enjoyed the show tonight!

Katherine can sing, but she "bores me". Sounds like the same song every week to me. Taylor and Chris were my favorites.

 

[RyMickey]

Well, this is my favorite genre of music and the Idols didn't disappoint tonight.

- Chris was surprisingly good, although I think the song is overrated.

- Paris was good, but I didn't really dig the Billie Holliday vibe I was getting from her.

- Taylor - What can I say? He's great fun to watch. It wasn't his best performance, but at the end, he was a hoot to watch.

- Elliot disappointed me, honestly. I think the arrangement of the song was cheesy and he was simply okay.

- Kellie better be in the bottom three this week. I want her to go home, but that might be asking too much. But she better be in the bottom three. Simply awful!

- If Kellie doesn't go him, Ace better. I thought he was lousy this week.

- Katharine sang one of my favorite songs ever. And she didn't disappoint. Granted, my McPheever may make me biased, but I agree with Simon that she was, by far, the best tonight.

 

[cheerbop]

Other than Kellie, who is NOT my fave but honestly usually does well...

I thought tonight was FABULOUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This type of music really shows off their voices.

 

[damo]

Kellie, Taylor (my daughter used to dance like him when she was 3 and had to pee really badly) and Ace were my bottom. Elliott could be interchangable with any of them.

However, I doubt very, very much that Kellie and Taylor will be bottom 3. It probably will be Ace, Elliott and Paris with Ace leaving.

 

[Philadisney]

i thought everyone was, at the very least, enjoyable tonight (well i have to admit i flipped channels while kellie was singing...but she looked cute....)
many people were GREAT! which makes me a bit worried for my man elliott i have been trying and trying though, and have only gotten through once!
i agree with the poster who said kathryn can sing, but is boring. also with her hair pulled back she reminded me of mikaylah tonight overall though, i really enjoyed the show tonight!

 

[wdwgirl03]

^ ^ I have still not gotten through at all for Elliott. I really hope he doesn't go.

 

[TnKrBeLlA012]

My favorites were Chris and Katherine. It will be very hard to pick between the two. The bottom three for me would be, Ace,Kelli,and Paris. I would hope Ace will be the one to go. Every week I think it's his week. This week I think is the one.

 

[palmtreegirl]

Chris-Really good. I loved it. Didn't love the outfit though.

Paris-Her best vocal performance so far but I found it a bit boring.

Taylor- I just love him.

Paula, please put the girls away

Elliot- Awesome. I love that song so I was skeptical before he started but it was really, really good.

Totally disagree with Simon, I thought this was Elliots best performance to date

Kellie- Beginning was cute but then it got really tight and pitchy. Wasn't her best, that's for sure but she'll be around next week.

Ace- He sounded really great in the clip with Rod Stewart. Tonight he wasn't as good but I enjoyed it. Didn't care for hair.

Katherine- Not a fan of Katherine but I thought she was great tonight. This is definitely her genre.

 

[Nancy]

Here is my list for tonight:

Favorite to least favorite

1. Katharine
2. Chris
3. Taylor
4/5/6(they are interchangeable) Ace/Paris
Eliott
7. Kellie

Bottom 3: I think will be Ace, Elliot and maybe Kellie or Paris. Going home either Ace or Elliot, probably Ace.

It is getting harder and harder to pick 3 for the bottom...I can pick the worst..that would be Kellie tonight, but the guys will vote her through.

 

[aprilgail2]

I liked Chris Paris and Taylor...Katherine was good too....
Elliot-boring and downright creepy!
Kellie-boring and dumb as a stump!
Ace-boring and icky and I can not stand that falsetto that he does!
Hopefully one of those three will be history tomorrow!

 

[DaisyD]

I thought they all sounded great tonight. Surprisingly I got through a few times for Chris and Taylor but only once for Elliott. The phones were jammed for him. Go Elliott!