American Idol: Season 11 OFFICIAL thread!

[asta]

Philip Phillips should get to object to the way he sang Georgia on behalf of everyone from Georgia.

 

[DarthKTrava]

Deandre was all over the place with that song. Georgia was NOT really on his mind.

 

[fairestoneofall]

i thought Erika truly "sang for her life." she deserves to go through. she did MUCH better now versus last night.

 

[EllenFrasier]

Don't know Lady GaGa's songs, but I liked Erika!!!

 

[Robinrs]

I like Erika's voice in this song. I love voices with a bottom to it and she has it.

Hate that purple dress, though. Not a good look for her.

 

[Nancy]

honestly, most falsettos are not pretty. i'm trying to think of a falsetto that i enjoy and i'm drawing a blank. and the back and forth IS garbage.

I think Justin Timberlake gets it right. And going back old school..Frankie Valli.

 

[fairestoneofall]

I like Erika's voice in this song. I love voices with a bottom to it and she has it.

Hate that purple dress, though. Not a good look for her.

was it worse than her early 1990s jacket with monstrous shoulder pads and sheer sleeves? it was a slight improvement over her look last night.

she needs a stylist.

i love low voices (I have a low voice). i definitely thought she was better tonight.

 

[Nancy]

I like Erika's voice in this song. I love voices with a bottom to it and she has it.

Hate that purple dress, though. Not a good look for her.

I liked her too. She did a awesome job with that song.

 

[lillygator]

Bummed who they are picking to sing for their life. Deandre...really?

 

[Nancy]

Too bad for a few of them that they wasted a spot with Brielle..they should have picked Adam over her.

 

[fairestoneofall]

make it a top 11 with Erika and call it a day.

he is obnoxious. he went from a lounge lizard to an... i'm not sure.

you cannot beat box like Blake. don't even try.

 

[EllenFrasier]

Who was that guy last season who sang all the Rod Stewart songs? Had blonde hair? Reed reminds me of him. I didn't like him either.

 

[Robinrs]

I think Justin Timberlake gets it right. And going back old school..Frankie Valli.

Russell Thompkins Jr from the stylistics

Eddie Kendricks, the Temptations

and of course the King of Falsetto, Phillip Bailey.

For today's music, Robin Thicke reigns!

 

[Mean Queen]

Reed is doing much better today, less cheesy. I think he'll make it through along with Erica and maybe Deandre or Jeremy.

 

[Nancy]

What a waste.

 

[Cogswel_Cogs]

make it a top 11 with Erika and call it a day.

he is obnoxious. he went from a lounge lizard to an... i'm not sure.

you cannot beat box like Blake. don't even try.

TA


Totally Agree

 

[mandy200587]

I don't dig any of the wild cards. Team Skylar and Dixon

 

[fairestoneofall]

notice they are not exactly complimenting him.

 

[Nancy]

Russell Thompkins Jr from the stylistics

Eddie Kendricks, the Temptations

and of course the King of Falsetto, Phillip Bailey.

For today's music, Robin Thicke reigns!

All good choices.

 

[GoofyforDisney3]

Steven will pick Reed
JLo will pick Deandre
Randy will pick Ericka