We liked it enough to eventually return, but it wasn't mind-blowing or anything. The theming is very well done and our service was good. Our food choices (falafel, corn cake app, and the pork dish) were basically all, "I've had a better version of this elsewhere, but it's not bad."
But as a couple who aren't huge planners and don't care for character meals, in MK our sit-down dinner choices are basically the Plaza, Tony's, Liberty Tree, and the Skipper Canteen. I'm glad for a decent addition to that small and not-great lineup. We can't eat at the Plaza every time!