You have to do what you have to do to get consistency. Trust me, in the line i work in, i'm used to it. If on thursday they deny me, I will politely ask for anyone who can help me. Because there has to be some kind of consistency. Period.
And there will be.
Disney will probably fix this loophole next year. (Or maybe tomorrow?)
As I said in another thread we are sometimes victims of our own success. We post the "exceptions" that someone makes and they become the rule. If that's not what management wanted the system is fixed so that there is no way for a CM to "bend" the rule.