Comparing FQ and CBR:
I really liked FQ and would definately stay there again. We were looking for something different this year, as DF has stayed at FQ the past three years in a row. Love the atmosphere and especially being on the little river with the boat ride to DTD. One of my favorite things is the little walkway between FQ and Riverside, I thought that was very romantic.
That said, the themeing at CBR is my new favorite for moderates and value resorts, its really cute! Atmosphere and all the bright colors really makes this a nice place. all the different "islands" or whatever are situated around the little lake with sandy beaches. The pool is IMO about the same themeing wise as the one in FQ. The big pool draw here though, is, all the quiet pools they have around the different sections. That is something you don't need QUITE as much in FQ because its much smaller there. CBR is much bigger and spread out. We were staying about as close as you can get to the Food Court/ Main Pool area though, so we didn't use the quiet pools really. The rooms are a little bigger at CBR but not noticeably so. I just loved the colorful rainbow spreads compared to the kind of drab colors in FQ.
The really big thing I liked about CBR is the food court. MUCH improved on FQ. A lot more selection! If all you want out of the food court is a place to get a hamburger and sodas in your mug, FQ is absolutely fine. But if you're like us and come back for naps and such during the day, and eat at the resort a couple times during the week, the many options they have are nice and the food's not that bad either.
I really like both resorts and would go back to either one. I asked DF what he likes about the two of them comparatively, and his response was he likes the music that plays along the little pathways in the FQ

lol
Wareagle: honestly, if it was me, I'd keep the AS ressie and save the money, because my DF always manages to talk me up into a moderate when I am trying to save money $$$ lol. However we went to the Poly this time and I fell in love with it, so now I'm trying to angle for a deluxe resort. I think you'll probably be plenty happy with the AS, and you can use the extra money for more food and souveniers. I haven't been to a value disney resort though, so I don't know. You might want to visit CBR while you are there, and your DH might see that he really does like it and want to stay there next time
I hope all of this helps and if I'm confusing you all even more let me know!
