We stayed at the All Stars our first few years and found them to be a very good value as we aren't in the room or at the resort much. The pools are nice, they are laid out well and are a good value for the price. Having said that, the biggest reason we moved is because the last 2 times we stayed there, it was becoming more crowded and much more noisy so we decided it was time to upgrade. Disney service is Disney service no matter where you stay on property. Have a wonderful trip! You won't be disappointed.