Another important point is that if you stay over the beginning of a month it’s very hard—we like to visit around Thanksgiving, so we can’t do Dec use year because our trips extend from Nov-Dec. April would be tricky for those who go over spring break, etc.
Guys this chain was in the ROFR thread (I don’t know why), but it got me thinking about how UY pertains to FW.
So if I like to travel in August and my use year is in August is that bad
As long as you don't plan to overlap with July travel then it's great, because the use year starts August 1.
I get this, and am glad my first entry into this subgenre is a subsidized AUL OV 1BR DEC UY FW52.
The closer to the start of a UY your trip is, the more flexibility and options you have to make sure you don’t have points at risk of being lost.
Yes but if I were to opt out of my FW52 in 2024 and book Thanksgiving week of 2024 instead, that would be considered risky. The logic is: if I had to cancel after July 31, 2024 (after banking window) then my 2023 points would be in distress.
But on the other hand, if I had kept FW52 but had to cancel after banking window closes (July 31, 2024), wouldn’t I still be in the same boat (risking my DEC 2023 UY points)?
Doing this thinking exercise (cuz thinking about UY strains my brain), I see we cannot choose any other UY than the one in which our FW resides (for the 12-mo booking window using points previous to the travel year). But…
For regular contracts, wouldn’t April UY (and not DEC) be ideal for travel that occurs entirely in DEC? Reason being, if you cancel anytime before Dec and 31days before your checkin, you could still bank your points??
Apologies if this question turns out to be a long walk off a short plank.

. I do make assumptions like the 12-m reservation will be made using prior year’s points…