We've stayed at AKL-Jumbo (nov 07) and AKL-Kidani (july 09). In '07, before Kidani was built, I thought the busing system was better than any other resort I've had at. Even though you can't walk to a park, take a monorail, or a boat, the buses were frequent and never overcrowded. I prefer an all-busing system such as this vs having 4+ bus stops in 1 resort (CSR, OKW, CBR) or sharing a bus with other resorts (CR, GF, Poly, BC/YC, BWI, Swan/Dolphin). The location of WL is no better than AKL because WL is only close to MK and VERY far from everything else (just like all other MK resorts). The AKL is very close to AK (bus every 5 mins too), not too far from Epcot and DHS-- farther from DTD and MK. AK is also very close to Blizzard Beach.
Now that Kidani is open, Jumbo and Kidani share buses but even for July 4th week, the buses were never over-crowded. The park buses go to Kidani Village and then to Jumbo House. The DTD bus goes to Jumbo House and then to Kidani Village.
We've eaten at all the restaurants at the resort and love them! They have foods that you cannot find anywhere else and the QS (Mara) is great!
We are staying at SSR (our waitlist didn't come through for AKL) next weekend and we'll go to AKL to eat at Mara or Boma on our AK day! Honestly, AKL isn't my personal favorite resort but it's in the top 3! Take my opinions for what they are worth because I've never stayed at WL. I've been there a few times for dinner, but that doesn't make me an expert on comparing the WL to AKL, just offering information on the AKL. Hope the info helped!!
Either way, once you make your decision, try not to wishy washy about it. Be happy about it and confident that things will go well and will be fine!

Remember this, people seem to always find so many things to be picky about, complain about, and unhappy about. Remember that the grass is not always greener on the other side and Disney doesn't have a "perfect" resort. Each resort has its own things that make it special in 1 way or another. Find out what your family values most and make your decision based on that. No resort will be without flaws, but be excited that you're going to Disney World!!!
