westonkamom
Mouseketeer
- Joined
- Nov 28, 2010
- Messages
- 172
What a terrible dilemma you have!!!Both resorts are beautiful; both are comparable.......... decisions, decisions!!
I am a very big fan of split stays. Disney really makes it pretty easy! Since your family is planning a 2-week trip, any chance you could split - a week at WL and a week at AKL? That's what I would do if I had your "problem"!
If a split stay is out of the question, you really do have a very hard decision to make! "Location" seems to me to be the only real difference. AKL, to me, is always like a vacation within a vacation. Once you get back to the resort, the peace, quiet and beauty of the place makes me feel far removed from the "theme park vacation"! WL is also beautiful and often peaceful & quiet too, but you can look across the lagoon and see MK and really feel immersed in the magic!Whatever your decision, you're going to Disney World!! It doesn't get much better than that!
![]()
I agree, a split stay would be awesome! Only issue is we're booked with FD. I think the park ticket requirement with that promo would add a bit too much onto an already pricey trip, lol. I'll have to do the math again though and relook at that option. Honestly, if the Poly wasn't under so much construction, we all agreed we'd love to stay there....not sure it'd be worth the price this year though. Thanks for your input

....I don't know if you know this, but the architect/designer is the same for both lodges, so there are marked similarities between both. I've stayed at both; you can't miss at either one. However, since you are going during Christmas, hands-down the WL is, by far, the BEST DECORATED RESORT for the Holidays....
Yes, we read that the same architect designed both, which is why it's such a hard decision, lol!! I thought for sure you'd say AKL at Christmas! Maybe I just didn't explore WL enough when we visited. It might just be that I really don't like WCC and it being right off the beautiful lobby just felt like it detracted away from the beauty to me. Thanks for sharing your choice!! I think we're going to have to flip a coin on this one.

I am quite jealous of your dilemma!! I also vote split stay - I hear it's pretty easy! We were really stuck deciding between AKL and WL... would have done a split stay if we were staying longer. Went for the animals for my son, to offset all the princess for my daughter
WL has the boat to MK, I think that's an advantage over AKL, although not having stayed there, not sure how well it all works out.
I think the FD promo is going to keep us from doing a split stay bc of the park ticket purchase requirement. To buy a 2 day and an 8 day is more expensive than just the 10 day, especially for 4. Maybe if an amazing RO comes out that could be an option! I agree that the boat is an awesome advantage, but I'm just concerned that with December weather being so unknown in FL it might not actually end up something being used much. We used a boat a couple times in early December 2011 when the weather was pretty good to get from the Poly back to MK and also MK to HDDR and it was chilly. I think it's going to come down to a coin toss!!!

Okay, here's the thing. We live 3 hours from Wisconsin Dells and could visit a resort with a similar theme to WL for a fraction of the cost. I think that's why it's not really appealing to me. That up-north theme (not exactly like WL but similar), while beautiful but obviously not at WDW, is easily accessible to us in MN. I think DH, the arborist (tree doctor), found his niche at WL and that's why he likes it so much. Is it wrong that I am mainly basing my choice of AKL on the food offerings????
