I think it depends on how your child reacts to characters...we went to WDW in Jan and my DS is 2 - he was a little nervous at first when around characters, but by the end of the day, he was fine with them and enjoyed the autograph book - we take a Creative Memories Disney 8x8 album and have one signature per page and then add pic when we get home - my two sons loved it! But if he is too afraid of characters, I wouldn't want to "tortune" him anymore than needed...