I can't believe I read all that!
AH!
Ok, so my comment on the OP
1) It's really hard to compare based on a single-day ticket since most tickets are multi-day passes so most people don't nearly pay $85 a day realistically. yes, there are the odd uneducated tourists who think WDW is like any other theme park and walk up to the gate to buy admission, but I think most people either call the 800# or do some research and end up with multi-day tickets and pay in the neighborhood of $50/day.
2) I am kind of upset about prices going up and it does FAR outpace inflation. When we bought out first AP in 2004 I think it was just above $400. With tax, our APs this year were close to $600 :-O. Before MYW, APs became "worth it" at 8 days, now it's much harder to make that calculation. I think it's like 14 days now. I also feel Disney doesn't do as much for Passholders as I wish they would BUT I can see why they don't as the average passholder spends less per trip than the once in a lifetime vacationer.
3) I can't stand MYW. I'm always helping people plan their trips and no one understands them. It's no confusing. They rolled it out as being a way to SAVE money when really it costs so much more. I feel like the old tickets were easier to understand and were fair, but I do understand what they're trying to do in terms of keeping people OP.
4) Of course they have a right to charge as much as they want and make a profit. keep in mind though that when you're thinking about overall company profit and CEO salary, that theme parks are just one small piece of the Disney pie. They'll charge what they have to to keep the Thme Parks division profitable, but don't think that Iger's salary is dependent on how many churros you buy. I think it has a lot to do with supply and demand and also the costs of keeping a theme park running. Disney is very good at responding to changes in demand by running promotions such as free dining or kids stay and play free. They're in tune with the market. They aren't going to have empty parks.
I had already decided we were going to take 2 trips, one this December, and one next October, but had I not had that completely in my head, I may have thought twice about buying APs. The rates are high and the Pin code rates are lower right now.
Another thing I don't think anyone has brought up is that people CONSTANTLY complain that the parks are going "downhill", that monorails don't run as often, paint is chipped, AAs are down (hello Disco yeti), rides are in bad need of refurbishment, etc. Well these things cost money. The company isn't going to constantly dump money from other parts of the corporation into Theme Parks to keep them up, they have to be profitable on their own. At some people there will be a trade off. Either you can accept deteriorating quality for lower prices, or you're willing to pay more for a superior experience (the latter was Walt Disney's philosophy). Now, we can argue a few things..one the price is going up and the quality is going down, and that is not acceptable. You can argue that they're putting profit ahead of guest experience. At some point though, that balance will shift and people won't be willing to pay the extra money to come to Disney World.
Maybe my price perceptions are skewed having lived in NYC my entire life, but I don't feel "bilked" by Disney. I feel that in general the prices are fair or close to fair. Most of my nights at POP are costing $66. $66 for a room I know will be clean and comfortable with direct bus service to all of the attractions at the most popular vacation destination in the world? With free airport pickup?
With my 2 trips, it will be under $40 a day for admission to Disney world. Under $40? I can ride unlimited rides. Next month I get to watch the Candlelight Processional..I don't need to pay extra for that incredible show. I don't have to pay extra to meet Mickey Mouse, or to watch the amazing parades and fireworks shows which can't even compare to anything at another park or at home (with the exception of the Macy's T-day parade and the 4th of July fireworks). That's not half bad.
You can't compare a Motel 6 in some podunk roadside town and a boardwalk amusement park to Disney. It's just not the same thing, and the prices have been going up there, too. If people get prioces out of Disney, they will continue to respond with discounts. Sure the ticket may be $50 a day, and maybe you are paying $82 for your value hotel, but FREE dining? That's an amazing deal.