4 meals for 4 people, then, so 16 consumed meals (4x4), I think $600 is pretty close. The thing about the dining plan is you have to buy it for length of stay, you can't pick and choose it. We also have TIW, and we've pretty much given up on buffets as my 17 year old never eats enough to be close to worth it. We also frequently aim to only eat 2 times per day (with a snack or two in there, of course), and schedule our TS for breakfast a lot of the time as late as possible. For example, this past weekend we went to Kona for breakfast at 10:50am (so think brunch). We had 10 of us, and after my TIW discount, the total bill was only $190 for all 10. But for lunch/dinner, we would expect to pay close to double that price. We will be back the end of the month for my daughter's birthday, and have late lunch reservations for 5 people, I expect that would be roughly a $200 meal. I'm not saying I like the pricing, I certainly don't! But then, if we go to Cracker Barrel with our 4, its still about $60-70, and that's not at Disney, I expect Disney pricing to be higher than off site.