50's PT or Tony's

[brandycaviness]

Which should I choose for lunch? I know they are completely different environments, but as far as food.

 

[thedude]

I would go with 50s. It is probably our favorite place to eat. Food is really good. I wasn't too impressed with Tony's the one time I ate there. It wasn't terrible, but nowhere near 50s in my opinion.

 

[BeerMe]

50s definitely

 

[moniqueelaine]

I have never been to Tony's I have however been to 50's, and we had the best dinner on our last trip, we laughed til we cried..the food is pretty good, but the enviroment is out of this world, well worth it

 

[mickeyplanner]

Going with the majority.....50s and make sure you get a Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake!!!
Tony's food is tasteless and the service is always slow. Don't waste your time but if you are looking for lunch at MK, I would pick Liberty Tree over Tony's. Their soups and salads are great and make sure to get the Toffey/Sticky Dessert thing.

 

[ScoJo15]

I'm not a fan of either one, but 50s is definitely better than Tony's.

 

[Raksha]

We love 50s!! It's definitely a staple on all visits for us....

 

[HadesTX]

50's. Nobody in my family liked Tony's.

 

[BuzzLiteyear]

We liked Tony's, but...we really loved 50's PTC. The food is great and the environment is awesome.

 

[Kelblum]

50s!!! We only went to Tony's once but we did not like it at all. If you have to have Italian go to Mama Melrose, Tutto or Via Napoli!

 

[goofyintoronto]

Going with the majority.....50s and make sure you get a Peanut Butter and Jelly Milkshake!!!>>>I agree, PB&J shake is amazing!!

Tony's food is tasteless and the service is always slow. Don't waste your time but if you are looking for lunch at MK, I would pick Liberty Tree over Tony's. >>>I also agree, I love liberty tree. so yum! Their soups and salads are great and make sure to get the Toffey/Sticky Dessert thing.

50's. Nobody in my family liked Tony's.

50s!!! We only went to Tony's once but we did not like it at all. If you have to have Italian go to Mama Melrose, Tutto or Via Napoli!

I agree with everyone about Tony's, it was the WORST food i've ever had in my life. I tried my son's meatball and couldnt swallow it, it was that gross. The marinara sauce killed both dishes i think. I'd definitely go with 50's! Its quite yummy, and fun!

 

[NorweJenNY]

I wouldn't say Tony's is a bad place to go to. We enjoyed our meal there... but I agree with the general consensus that if given a choice between Tony's and 50s, definitely go with 50s.

50s has the ultimate in comfort food offerings... and I'm also a fan of the PB&J milkshake!

 

[GC&S]

We just did Tony's for the first time a couple of days ago. We did PT last year. Would definitely go with PT again. Tony's really has no theming - lots of pictures but nothing else. Food was mediocre. My shrimp scampi was just ok - only had flavor because of the roasted peppers and DH's steak was overdone (asked for med rare). DD didn't like her ravioli. Desserts were good. Waitress was nice.

 

[kathyfog]

Oh wow, I am so glad I found this, I did ADR for Tony's, now I think we will go somewhere else. Thanks for the information'
Kathy

 

[emmysmommy]

Another vote for 50s. I think the only thing that I liked at Tony's was the ice-cream sundae chocolate curls!

Seriously though, 50s has great decor and I love their comfort food menu options.