Just read through your whole TR this morning!

Love the pictures and the reviews.
I have a question for ya...Since you have three kids like me and are more experienced...I'm trying to decide where we will stay next time. Our kids will probably be 12, 7, 3. I was thinking the cabins because of the space, 2 rooms, bunkbeds, can park out front and how it's not connected to other people...3 kids = noise. We stayed at a value this year and it was just not enough room and now has me a little scared to stay in one room next time. So anyway, was thinking AKV 1 bedroom (has washer and dryer, extra room but nervous to rent points), cabins, POR or a deluxe that sleeps 5 like Poly, CR or BC. Just trying to figure out if there really is enough space in one room with 3 kids. Didn't mean to make that so long...Just wanted your opinion.

I'm seeing + and - to all... Not that worried about the pool...just convience and space.

Glad to have you follow along!
Hmmm...WDW has sooooo many choices for resorts. There are several things you might want to consider...how long are you going to be there? What parks will you visit the most? Are you ok with riding buses, or do you want other modes of transportation?
I've never rented points....it makes me a little nervous...but there are people who swear by it. Did you check out the DVC thread? I think that is where all the point stuff might be. I've read that OKW has really big villas...lots of room for a family, and they tend to be a bit cheaper than some of the rest. Also, make sure you check out the discounts/codes/pins...we haven't paid rack rate for a room in ages.
If you are looking to be close to the MK, you cant beat the Poly or CR...CR being much cheaper. You can get a GW room for a really great price. With 3 kids, I think the room is fine. If my children were all in their teens, then that might be a different story. With the deluxe resorts, you get queen size beds, too.
FW was great, too. My only complaint was the double bed. DH is use to a queen. I think my parents said they were actually ok. What's great about FW is the two rooms...plenty of space to spread out. It's such a wonderful place for a family with young children...so much to do there...just save your money and rent the golf cart!
We would really like to try the 1 bedroom at BLT...has plenty of room, plus the washer and dryer....and not to mention the Monorail (my favorite benefit of the MK resorts)
Just recently, I was following along on a TR and asked if POR would be okay for my family of 5...she said it might be a little cramped even though there is a trundle bed. Those rooms aren't that much bigger than the values. If you can swing it, then I would certainly go with FW or a 1 bedroom villa...that's going to give you the most room for sure. And if your kids are like mine...they fight! Extra space is always needed
Not sure if that helped or not...or perhaps confused you more!! Have you checked out Allears.net??? Tons of great info over there. There may be some others on this thread that can help you out.
Happy Planning! I'll be anxious to see what you decide on!
Heather