A Gift is just that... A GIFT. It is not a demand to be made by the receiver. It is a fortunate coincidence when someone cares enough about you to purchase something special for you for any occassion. WHAT the thing is does not matter much, you should be grateful for the mere fact that someone has cared enough about you or your child to put the thought and time into buying a gift.
Telling people what to buy is in essence dictating someone elses kindness... and it loses some of the point. If a gift giver asks for recommendations then OK, tell them what you think the child would appreciate most.
However the most important thing is to be grateful for WHATEVER happens to show up in the gift wrap. I think too many people have lost this very basic ettiquette in regards to gifts. If you truly hate it, you can always donate it later or return it. But don't dictate gifts, try to be happy somebody loves you enough to give them.
I don't care if it is a gift wrapped turd, if that turd given with kind intent than I will thank someone for it and be happy that in some weird way they cared.
BTW: At age 17 my grandmother brought a friend to our family Christmas party. To be kind, the friend wanted to buy a gift for the grandchild (me). After hearing my grammy talk about me, she assumed I was 3. I received a pink plastic pretend tea time set. You can bet that even though it wasn't right for me, my face lit up! I smiled and profusely thanked the friend for being *thoughtful* enough to get me a gift which I could take with me when I babysat. I babysat for two families with small girls and procalimed the tea set to be absolutely perfect to bring along. I can't tell you how relieved that woman looked after that.
I completely, 100% agree with you!!!


I just don't have the energy right now
BUT I agree, a kid is going to like any doll or any action figure or any truck or train you get them -- and they will never once say, "I don't like this doll because I've never seen the TV show." As long as it's cute or shiny or whatever (especially at 2 years old!), they'll be happy.
I was going to say this!! LOL
DD had one too and actually loved it.