I am glad I found this thread. I have been second guessing my ADR choices recently. I was thinking about changing LeCellier to Coral Reef. Because of this thread I think I will. The food sounds great as well as sitting next to the aquarium. My oldest daughter wants to work as a marine biologist or a trainer at Sea World, so she would definately like it!
I think it just goes to show that people do have different experiences at all restaurants. I have memories of great meals here and some of the negative posts had me leary. Now I think we will definitely go there.