Alright Mutt, I did my research..........Did you do yours?
After 1 1/2 hrs of reading through posts on various websites, here are a few things I came up with:
1. EVERYONE has an opinion.
2. For every positive, there is a negative.
3. People REALLY like the Painkillers on the Doubloon...........
Doubloon: I really didn't read anything negative about this one. I know most of you have done this and I can understand wanting to change things up. The later departure time seems to be the only thing anyone didn't like.
Capt. Nautica: If we could team up on this, I think it would be really fun. There were only a few negatives on this and most had to do with the fact that their itinerary changes. I think this is a positive though. It means that they pay attention to the currents and the weather, and take you where you are most likely to see more. My DS and I might as well have fins, so the extra hour of snorkeling is appealing to me. Plus, you get to spend a little time on one of the beaches, usually Honeymoon Beach. Not sure DH wants to snorkel for 2.5 hours, but then I didn't ask...........
St. John/Trunk Bay: Not happening for me. This by far had the most negative comments and I don't want to risk it. Most everyone said the beach was gorgeous but wish they'd had been able to get there on their own. Since the time is so limited the beach experience was short and almost everyone said the snorkeling itself was jus okay. I'm cruising
DCL, I expect more than okay
Let me know what your thoughts are (as if I really had to ask for them

)
St. Maarten: definitely "winging it"