YC vs Swan vs Poly

[snwarf]

I know everyone probably gets tired with the debates...but I am second guessing and triple guessing and....you get the picture!
I've stayed at the Poly and (sorry) am not overwhelmed with love for it...other than it is on the monorail.
I love the idea of the Yacht club...with the pool and concierge etc..
I can't beat the price of the swan (& I'm still getting concierge).
I mean, it is THOUSANDS cheaper than the Poly Or YC.

So basically, we are going in mid June so the pro's are:
Poly - less walking with the monorail
YC - great pool & close to my fav park
Swan - cheap & heavenly beds

Honestly, if you could pick one without hesitation...which would it be? It will be concierge for any of the three we pick.

Thanks!

 

[dandave]

I have stayed at the Dolphin, BC, and Poly- but I didn't stay at concierge/club level at any of those.
My preferences in order were : BC, Poly, then Dolphin. Of the three, I would only look forward to returning to the BC.
Have fun wherever you stay!

 

[Bojangles]

I was not very impressed with the concierge service at our last Polynesian trip. I would choose YC or Swan. I like them both equally.

 

[robinb]

I would save THOUSANDS and stay at the Swan. The hotel is quite nice and you can use your savings to eat at a few special places like Shulas at the Dolphin .

Book the Swan now and then keep an eye on the rates at the YC for your time period. Maybe it's come down and your savings won't be so substancial.