Yachtman or Narcoosee?

[abc999]

Which is better, Yachtman's Steakhouse or Narcoosee's?

 

[Tikitoi]

We've done both. And for whatever reason did not get such a kick out of Yachtsman. Maybe I just ordered the wrong dish or something. But as far as Narcoossees loved everything about it. From the fresh tasty salad to the tender steak and delicious lobster. And as an extra we had a Cinderella slipper for desert. Narcoossees all the way!

 

[Pakey]

We've eaten at both a few times and they are a very different experience both in atmosphere and food so I think it's very hard to compare them.

Narcoosees have a lovely setting at the GF and out on the water, but strictly speaking food wise, the fish/seafood at Flying Fish and bluezoo is much better and certainly more unique. And our last two times here, it's been so noisy in the restaurant that it's been hard to enjoy the meal. It was like dining at a Red Lobster. One time, I'd think it was an oddity, but twice in a row makes me think it's the norm.

Yachtsman is your typical upscale steakhouse. On the menu, you have beef and more beef. I have enjoyed my salads, appetizers and desserts here but I've been underwhelmed with the steaks. The atmosphere has always been fairly adult and quiet and we've enjoyed sharing a nice bottle of wine and relaxing.

Although neither are my top choices, if I had to pick between the two, I would pick Yachtsman.

 

[ransom]

Definitely go with Narcoossee's.

 

[allisonswonderland]

Um I will not be much help - we enjoy them both. But I am not a crazy seafood fan, so when I got to Narcoossees I get a steak but my husband gets seafood, but at Yachtsman he gets a steak ( um I do too, hehehe) so would you like seafood or a steak - that would be how I would make my decision. I love Narcoossees fish chowder, though.

The atmosphere at Yachtsman is MUCH quieter...in fact sometimes I feel like I am afraid to talk in there (not really it just seems so quite).

 

[abc999]

We love steak and seafood!!! I showed DH the menus and he said he was getitng hugry just reading the menus. I think we will go to both

 

[allisonswonderland]

Have a great meal at both places!!!

 

[OKW Lover]

We've done both and you'll be happy with which ever one you pick. YSH is in our top 3 WDW restaurants. Narcoossee's is close but not quite there for us.

I think your decision might be best made by looking at the menu's here on the DIS and deciding which more closely matches your taste. Just click on "dining" in the menu bar near the top of this page to see the menus for all the WDW restaurants.